Vivian Lewis Blog | How I Would Vote In Israel | TalkMarkets
Editor and founder of Global-Investing.com
Contributor's Links: Global Investing
Vivian Lewis is editor and founder of Global-Investing.com, the daily blog newsletter for Americans and others seeking to internationalize their portfolios. She brings unique experience and competence to the business of picking foreign stocks. After graduating from Harvard magna cum laude (and ...more

How I Would Vote In Israel

Date: Monday, March 16, 2015 5:34 PM EST

Tomorrow is Israeli election day and also Saint Patrick's Day. Normally I would not get into politics in the Holy Land, leaving the election to my six Israeli first cousins and their offspring. But after my own country's politics were disrupted by an unprecedented Israeli intervention I feel I have the right to retaliate.

Be informed that in tomorrow's poll, I back the Israeli politician with the closest links to Ireland, the opposition leader, Isaac (Yitzhak) Herzog. He is the grandson and namesake of Isaac Levi Herzog, chief rabbi of Ireland in the 1930s. Rabbi Herzog, born in Belfast to Lithuanian immigrants, worked to unify the Auld Sod. He lived in Dublin and was able to speak Gaelic when required to.

Rabbi Herzog later made aliyah and went to Israel where he later became chief rabbi as well. With him went his Dublin-born son, Chaim Herzog (né Vivian, a man's name in Britain), later a famed diplomat and the President of Israel. Both Rabbi Herzog and his son famously walked in New York's St. Paddy's Day parades to the astonishment of my parents. “Only in America” as my father used to say.

Israel and Ireland both wanted independence from the British Empire then.

The leader of the United Zionist opposition to Likud's Benjamin (Binyamin) Netanyahu is Chaim Herzog's son.

Netanyahu is running scared. Today he stated that he would block a 2-state solution allowing Palestinian rule over most of the West Bank, something he has allegedly supported in negotiations the USA has been organizing for decades. “As long as I am leader, Israel will keep the West Bank”, he roared. This appeal to the hardest-line Israeli settlers defies US and Israeli supporters of peace.

Moreover, in an astonishing break from his normally overconfident manner, Netanyahu apologized for failing to adequately address Israel's high cost of living during his term of office. He has also earlier blustered his way into a foreign policy split with Israel's chief defender, the USA, by an ill-considered partisan address to Congress.

Evidence of his panic includes his tacking both left and right in Israeli economic policy, a key concern of the electorate. Premier Netanyahu offered the post of minister of finance to Kulanu party leader Moshe Kahlon, himself formerly of Likud to try to split the opposition. This led to a sell-off in the Tel Aviv stock market yesterday, for fear that anti-business Kahlon might get the job.

“I can't form a government without him,” Netanyahu told Israel Army Radio. He added: “Together, Kahlon and I will be able to solve the housing problem and the cost of living problem just as we dealt with the mobile telephone market”. Kahlon himself brushed off the offer because Netanyahu had made offers of finance ministry and other cabinet posts to him in the past which he did not followed up.

Then in Tel Aviv yesterday, PM Netanyahu pleaded with right-wing voters to “stop a left-wing government from coming to power.” He said: “Our rivals are investing in a huge effort to harm me and Likud, to open a gap between my party, the Likud, and [United Zionist] rivals. If we don't close this gap, there is a real danger a left-wing government will rise to power.”

We know Netanyahu from his days as Israeli UN Ambassador, as a slick power-mad politician. I think he is losing his touch.

There is a famous tale of how a scorpion persuades a frog to take him across a river, promising not to sting him and drown them both. But as they get near the further shore, he stings the frog anyway. The frog says: “Why did you sting me? We will both now drown.” To which the scorpion replies, “this is the Middle East.”

Disclaimer: This and other personal blog posts are not reviewed, monitored or endorsed by TalkMarkets. The content is solely the view of the author and TalkMarkets is not responsible for the content of this post in any way. Our curated content which is handpicked by our editorial team may be viewed here.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.
Or Sign in with
Gary Anderson 8 years ago Contributor's comment

I just saw this article and I am proud of you, Vivian. While we may not fully agree on all things about Israel, (and I don't know that for sure), I am for pushing the peace process forward. Not sure it would be changed by a popular vote but it could if Israel perceived a solution to be in its national interest.

Vivian Lewis 8 years ago Author's comment

well we both lost as did at least two of my Israeli cousins whose vote went to Herzog.

Derek Snyder 9 years ago Member's comment

Bibi lost my respect long go. That being said, it's hard to find any politician I respect these days and there are many who are far worst in the US and abroad (like Putin)!

Duanne Johnson 9 years ago Member's comment

Politicians say what they have to say to get elected. This is no different so why hold him to a higher standard? The best indication of what he will do if elected, is what he's done before. But whether you should vote for him or not also depends on who else is running...

People are free to support whichever party/candidate they wish - to each their own. But I'm curious as to why you support Herzog. You list his credentials as being he had a great grandfather. So what? What has the man who is running for office actually done himself to be worthy of a vote? I'm not asking to be critical, but am seriously asking as I've never heard of the man.

Corey Gaber 9 years ago Member's comment

This is an inaccurate statement: "But after my own country's politics were disrupted by an unprecedented Israeli intervention I feel I have the right to retaliate."

Why would you say that? Netanyahu was invited to Congress to speak in defense of his country. And he did not accept the invitation until after he called the White House. On the contrary, he is the victim of politics between Congress and Obama, and Obama's own personal dislike of Bibi. In fact, Obama has sent his own advisors and spent $350,000 dollars of US tax payer dollars to try to disrupt the Israeli elections and get Bibi ousted. There is now an investigation about this and both Democratic and Republican sides of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations have signed off on the probe, which shows it is not just a political plow:

www.foxnews.com/.../senate-committee-probes-whether-obama-administration-funded-effort-to-oust/

Dick Kaplan 9 years ago Member's comment

I saw this as well and was outraged that US tax dollars were used in such an inappropriate and illegal way. That being said, I was pretty disturbed by the recent about face on the 2-state solution. It does reek of last minute political desperation to me.

Danny Straus 9 years ago Member's comment

I like your work, but I have to respectfully disagree here. Americans have a tendency to state opinions about foreign elections from the safety of their homes. As someone who holds Israeli citizenship, I am the one who has to deal with rockets landing on my home if we elect the wrong leader. As for Bibi's recent announcement that he would not support a two-state solution, he means with the PA's current leadership. It is hard to make peace with someone who won't stop trying to kill you.

Frank Underwood 9 years ago Member's comment

I too, was very surprised by Netanyahu's announcement regarding the two state solution. He has always supported it in the past. Either he has come to realize that Israel currently has no peace partner or, as you said, he's become a bit desperate and is grasping at straws to appeal to the right.