Coronavirus And Trump's Clever Inadequacy
Donald Trump wanted trade wars from way back. He said China was raping the USA economically. What he failed to understand was the scale of China's business model.
It has been said by Steven Roach that there are 300 million migrant workers in China. That almost equals the entire population of the United States. Many have problems getting to work. The factories have to produce goods to pay back loans. China is the largest economy in the world according to purchasing power parity.
It would be easier for the Chinese to buy their own products than for Americans to afford American made products. We had the wealthy Chinese developing a taste for American products in ever greater quantities until Trump started the trade war.
Trump and Coronavirus
Donald Trump introduced a serious trade war with China not seeing the Coronavirus Covid-19 on the horizon. He thought he was clever, but now the US government says the trade war hurt the US economy and it slowed the Chinese economy. Now Trump and the world face the virus from a weakened position to begin with.
Because Trump could not grasp the scale of the Chinese economy (they make things and we sell each other insurance), he cannot grasp the damage a credit crisis in China could have on the world. He panicked recently, saying that the US was open for business to sell GE motors to China's aviation system. Trump knows tax revenue is down. His tax cuts have made revenue collection inadequate. He also cannot afford a China collapse and has said as much.
As I say, Trump wanted world cooperation with China as well to slow the process of the virus, while Peter Navarro and hard-liners want only a break with China. This would be a disaster to our economy on top of the potential disaster facing us already.
But Trump has major blind spots. Sanctuary cities encourage illegal aliens to go to the police and to the hospital. The virus could spread more rapidly in none sanctuary cities. Again, being politically clever compromises safety.
How Dangerous Is Coronavirus?
The Coronavirus appears to be far more infectious than is the flu. It is thought to be 1000 times more contagious than was Sars. WHO started out doing damage control, but now is warning of a pandemic. It gives daily reports. Germany says it cannot track the carriers or exposed potential victims. 20 untracked people could cause a pandemic.
Only three states in the USA have kits that would adequately track those who have symptoms, and it appears that it can be spread by those with no symptoms. Trump says only wealthy people may be able to afford the vaccine which he is not funding with enough money anyway according to Democrats.
Donald Trump appears confused. He is in damage control but then says schools should plan for a pandemic. Even the fear of pandemic in the USA will crash an over-leveraged stock market. All this leverage could cost speculators a lot of grief, even to the point of endangering the financial system. It was one thing to restore confidence in the Great Depression. It is virtually impossible to restore confidence in a pandemic.
The above comments reflect a worst-case scenario that may not happen. Perhaps the cases will be milder in the United States and will pass. However, we have to consider people's perceptions as well. What will their movements be out and about if the pandemic strikes their towns and plans.
Look at Boeing as an example. This company was wounded with the Max plane that has multiple issues preventing it from flying. But now companies could cancel or delay orders if people fear to board any airline to anywhere because of Covid-19.
Look at Europe. The nations are already a sliver above recession. The banks are a mess and as Jeffrey P. Snider says, things already are not fine.
Coronavirus is potentially dangerous to humans and to the travel industry. We can hope it will pass gently but experts have warned that more than 1/2 of the entire US population could become infected with millions of deaths. One researcher predicted 40 to 70 percent of our population will be infected. The risk is greater for older people, with an 8 percent death rate for those between 70 and 79, and a 14+ percent death rate for those over 80. That includes much of the investor class.
I visited the Grand Canyon a year and a half ago. By far the most visitors were Chinese when I was there. This is true at various shopping venues as well. Wealthier Chinese were addicted to US products. Now many can't come, groups are banned, and many Chinese may not remain loyal in the future. Yellowstone Park is bracing for at least a 30 percent drop in visitors, Chinese visitors.
When a president plays fast and loose with supply and demand, with debt, with brand loyalty, he is only shooting his own citizens in their pocketbooks.
US Banks and China
One critical area of financial weakness could be American banks. While China is a creditor nation to the United State, owning a large portion of our treasury bonds, it as a nation borrows from US banks. US banks may be very vulnerable if their loans to China go bad.
China borrows from the world bank at about 1.3 billion dollars per year. It has borrowed billions in order to take advantage of world bank expertise. Steve Mnuchin argued against the loans, saying China loaned billions to poor nations. Oh, bad China. No, Mnuchin looks like Scrooge. But the world bank could be at risk in case of a default by China in this crisis period.
And in America, borrowers are using up for 55 percent of their income to by a house as they use alternate lenders. They may be a few paychecks from default. Can we dare imagine if these folks are walled off from work?
Banks appear to be quite vulnerable if the virus hits the USA hard. We hope for a better outlook, but there is no guarantee.
What does the Future Hold
We all hope that the virus passes without all the worst-case scenarios I have listed above. But it may require a militancy that we are seeing in China in order to confront the virus effectively. We may see stocks crumble, and small investors close to retirement may want to at least take out their initial investments. Predicting where stocks will go at this time is impossible.
I am already seeing masks being worn at the grocery stores. Is Trump being shielded from the stark reality already building? Is he in way over his head? Only time will tell.
Disclosure: I have no financial interest in any companies or industries mentioned. I am not an investment counselor nor am I an attorney so my views are not to be considered investment ...
Update 10: Counties with the most cases should be locked down longer. Trump wants to give people money. Should have been helicopter money from the Fed, but from the government the rates are low. And it may not be enough money for desperate families.
Update 9: Trump has banned flights from Europe, but with under 10000 test kits, Wall Street sees the possibility of the virus going out of control.
"Possibility?" More like a foregone conclusion!
I was being conservative. I am encouraged that big gatherings are being shut down. There needs to be more of that.
Agreed. Originally I thought we were overreacting. But the more I read about this pandemic, the more I realize that the US is woefully unprepared. More needs to be done.
Update 8: Donald Trump's continued clever behavior manifests in people applying for legal alien status being denied medical if they want permanent residency. This will likely guarantee the faster spread of the virus.
What I find nutty is that some people are actually blaming Trump for the virus.
That is nutty. I personally don't know anyone who is blaming Trump. Some are blaming Trump for his slow response and for not filling many empty CDC positions and for saying that people are overreacting just to remove him from office. Truth is, we do not know how the virus will impact the USA. It may be mild or terrible. We just don't know.
I did read online that several were trying to blame Trump. The problem in a situation like this is that it's tough to balance harsh measures which can force hardship on one's citizens, and damage the economy, and keeping people safe. But I fear that all this is now too little too late.
Once the cat is out of the bag, it's hard to get it back in. This virus will not die out in the US (or any place else) any time soon.
China has taken some very aggressive actions to make inroads against the virus. People are now recovering faster there than new people are being infected. But the country suffered greatly, both economically and in terms of the human toll. Will America go to the same lengths?
That is the big question Jack. I think Trump is wrong in saying it is safe to fly. It appears that Wall Street is voting exactly that way today. Trump is not going for massive quarantine, hoping to help stocks. But that decision could hurt stocks if the virus continues to spread.
Update 7: First death recorded in the USA. In Germany, out of 50 to 70 cases, almost half occurred today.
Great series of insights Gary.
All the best,
Arthur
Thanks prof. We hope it hits the US in a mild way, but if it doesn't, big events should be shut down at some point.
Update 6: Shopping malls, large gatherings, even Trump rallies could be hit hard if the Coronavirus spreads within our borders. There is a rumor among Trump followers that the virus is the result of a conspiracy to take Trump down. Putting oneself in the line of fire, medically speaking, to take down a president is absurd. No one could want this virus to take over the USA. If Trump would have taken charge from the beginning, months ago, instead of keeping silent, he could have avoided a lot of grief.
Update 5: China factories are up to 60 to 70 percent production. New cases are slowing in China. That is good news. Cases are increasing all over the world. Some governments are not ready. Some are. And some we aren't sure about.
Update 4: The Trump administration has warned Dr Anthony Fauci to no longer speak about the Coronavirus without government clearance. This is desperation and damage control, shutting up scientist. Trump is showing severe incompetence with this ill timed censorship.
Your point about the scale in China overwhelms that of the United States is so important. The Trump administration does not appreciate just how powerful the middle class is in China and how much this virus will hurt Chinese purchases from United States for both goods and services.
I agree prof.
Loading comments, please wait...