Photo by Steve Johnson on Unsplash

The cryptocurrency market has always been a rollercoaster of innovation, speculation, and volatility. In recent years, memecoins—cryptocurrencies born from internet memes or humorous concepts like Dogecoin, Shiba Inu, and newer entries like TRUMP or HAWK—have surged into the spotlight. Fueled by social media hype, celebrity endorsements, and retail investor fervor, memecoins have ballooned into a $100 billion-plus market segment by late 2024. While they’ve brought new users and excitement to crypto, their rise comes with serious downsides that threaten the industry’s credibility, stability, and long-term growth.

This article dives into the negative implications of memecoins, exploring how they distort markets, invite scams, undermine the promise of blockchain technology and interfere with market cycles by diverting and diluting liquidity that would otherwise go to promising projects with actual utility.

A Distorted Market: Speculation Over Substance

Memecoins thrive on hype, not utility. Unlike Bitcoin, designed as a decentralized currency, or Ethereum, a platform for smart contracts, most memecoins offer little to no real-world function. Their value hinges on viral attention—think Elon Musk tweeting about Dogecoin or Iggy Azalea launching Mother Iggy (MOTHER) with a cheeky butt-themed logo. This speculation-first approach sucks oxygen from projects with genuine innovation. In Q1 2024, top memecoins posted returns over 1,300%, outpacing many fundamentally strong altcoins. Retail investors, chasing quick riches, pour money into these tokens, leaving less capital for decentralized finance (DeFi), privacy coins, or scalable blockchains.

This skews the market’s priorities. Developers and founders of legitimate projects struggle to stand out amid the memecoin noise. Why grind on a complex protocol when a dog-themed token can hit a billion-dollar market cap overnight? The result is a “clown show” perception—regulators and traditional finance see crypto as a casino, not a transformative technology. Posts on X echo this frustration, with users lamenting how memecoins have “fucked the altcoin market” by turning it into “literal gambling.” The data backs this up: by December 2024, memecoins dropped 30% in market cap in a single month, dragging down broader sentiment as speculative bubbles burst.

More recently, we can see the following declines for leading memecoins in the past month:

DOGE -34%
SHIB -27%
PEPE -41%
TRUMP -57%
BONK -54%

Memecoins turn crypto into a speculative gamble, akin to a slot machine.

Memecoins’ low entry barriers—thanks to platforms like Pump.Fun, which spawned 4.7 million tokens in 2024—make them a breeding ground for scams. Rug pulls, where creators hype a coin then vanish with liquidity pool funds, are rampant. Take WSB Coin: launched in 2023 by a WallStreetBets moderator, it crashed after an insider dumped tokens, wiping out investors. Or $HAWK, tied to the “Hawk Tuah” meme, which peaked at $490 million in December 2024 before plummeting 95% as promoters cashed out. Nansen’s February 2025 report on Argentina’s $LIBRA memecoin is even grimmer: 86% of traders lost $251 million, while insiders pocketed $180 million.

Pump-and-dump schemes are just as common. Influencers and celebrities—like Caitlyn Jenner or Andrew Tate in 2024—hype tokens on social media, driving prices up before selling at the peak. Cointelegraph notes influencers now face fines for such antics, but the damage is done: latecomers, often less savvy retail investors, bear the losses. The blockchain’s transparency catches some culprits—X posts from 2024 warned “it’s forever immutable”—yet enforcement lags, and scammers adapt with fake presales or phishing tricks. This erodes trust in crypto, especially among newcomers lured by memecoin hype only to get burned.

Investors should be careful trusting social media personalities that only show their wins and ignore all of their losses. Most memecoin pumps require investors to be in within the first hour and out within another hour or two to capture any profit. It is mostly insiders that know about a coin launching ahead of the public that are able to capture large gains. In the equity markets, this is considered insider trading and is illegal and punishable by jail time.

Regulatory Blowback: A Hammer Waiting to Fall

Memecoins’ antics don’t just hurt wallets—they invite regulatory crackdowns. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has long eyed crypto for securities violations, and memecoins are low-hanging fruit. A July 2024 Cointelegraph piece flagged how celebrity shilling—like Jason Derulo’s token flops—could breach U.S. laws if marketed as investments. The Howey Test, which defines securities, considers “marketing” a factor; memecoin ads screaming “to the moon” fit the bill. Dogwifhat’s (WIF) $600,000 Las Vegas Sphere stunt in 2024? That’s a red flag to regulators.

When memecoins dominate, they paint crypto as unserious, slowing mainstream adoption. Serious players—banks, governments—hesitate to engage with a market where a squirrel-themed coin (PNUT) hits $1.2 billion after a viral euthanization story. Institutional investors, who tripled memecoin holdings to $204.8 million by March 2024, might rethink their bets if regulators clamp down. An X user in February 2025 warned Solana’s memecoin craze risks it becoming a “meme chain” under scrutiny, not a credible Layer 1 blockchain. The fallout? Tighter rules, higher compliance costs, and a harder road for legitimate projects. The industry has worked too hard for regulatory clarity and to remove regulatory risk, just to allow a small group of shady KOLs to profit from the demise of other crypto investors in a zero-sum game.

Memecoins’ wild ride could bring down the regulatory gavel on crypto.

Liquidity and Volatility: A House of Cards

Memecoins’ speculative nature creates a liquidity nightmare. With prices driven by tweets or TikTok trends, not fundamentals, they’re prone to violent swings. December 2024 saw a 32% memecoin market cap drop—from $137 billion to $92 billion—in weeks, per CoinMarketCap. Low liquidity amplifies this: sparse traders mean wide bid-ask spreads and easy manipulation. Whales can spike prices, then yank liquidity, leaving others stranded. High leverage in memecoin markets—common on decentralized exchanges—turns small dips into cascading sell-offs, as OneSafe’s blog noted in 2024.

This volatility spills over. When Dogecoin tumbled 25% post-Fed meeting in December 2024, it hit harder than Bitcoin’s dip, per Fortune Crypto. Memecoins’ “beta bet” status—leveraged plays on native tokens like Solana’s SOL—means their crashes can drag down bigger ecosystems. ScienceDirect’s 2021 study found memecoins’ positive net spillovers signal bubbles that crash leading coins like Bitcoin. Retail investors, burned by these swings, may abandon crypto entirely, shrinking the market’s base.

The Cultural Cost: Undermining Crypto’s Vision

Crypto began with a promise: decentralization, financial sovereignty, a better system. Memecoins mock that. They’re not about empowerment—they’re about “degeneracy,” as Azeem Khan told WIRED in January 2025. The focus shifts from building to gambling, from utility to absurdity. Medium’s Gaze All Over argued in 2024 that memecoins “represent everything wrong” with crypto’s value system, burying meaningful projects under hype. Even their upside—drawing newbies—fades when those newbies lose it all and leave disillusioned.

The community angle, a memecoin selling point, often masks grift. Shiba Inu’s ecosystem (Shibarium, ShibaSwap) tries to add utility, but most memecoins remain digital collectibles at best, Ponzi schemes at worst. X posts in 2025 called them “thousands upon thousands” of gambling tokens, diluting crypto’s ethos. If the market becomes a meme-fueled casino, the dream of a decentralized future fades.

AI Agents Offers Better Promise than Memecoins

AI agents can offer the same artistic and comedic value of a memecoin, but with actual utility. AI agents in cryptocurrency are autonomous software programs powered by artificial intelligence that operate within blockchain and crypto ecosystems to perform specific tasks with little to no human intervention. Think of them as smart digital assistants tailored for the fast-paced, decentralized world of crypto. Unlike traditional trading bots that follow rigid, pre-set rules, AI agents can learn, adapt, and make decisions based on real-time data, leveraging machine learning (ML), large language models (LLMs), and other AI techniques. They’re reshaping how users interact with cryptocurrencies, from trading to managing decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols, and even sparking new market trends.

Some AI agents have even built businesses autonomously, given access to crypto wallets to deploy capital into the real world. Some have created music, promoted it on social media and generated revenue from streaming songs all with little to no human intervention. Other AI agents are able to manage investment portfolios, filtering through magnitudes more data than a human could ever accomplish and doing it 24/7. Imagine a personal trader that never sleeps, constantly scans the market, and adjusts your portfolio while you’re offline—that’s an AI agent in crypto. With this great access to data, financials, emerging trends and the ability to trade faster on news, AI Agent investing bots or AI Agent hedge funds are already showing the promise to outperform human-led hedge funds or investment advisors by a wide margin.

AI agents follow a dynamic process:

• Data Collection: They pull in massive amounts of data—blockchain transactions, market prices, social media sentiment (e.g., X posts), news feeds, or even key opinion leader (KOL) chatter.
• Analysis: Using ML algorithms or LLMs (like those behind ChatGPT), they process this data to spot patterns, predict trends, or assess risks. For example, an agent might analyze 400+ influencers’ takes to gauge a token’s hype.
• Decision Making: Based on their analysis, they decide what to do—buy, sell, swap tokens, adjust a portfolio, or even mint a new coin.
• Execution: They act on-chain, interacting with smart contracts or wallets to carry out trades or other tasks autonomously.
• Learning: Over time, they refine their strategies, getting smarter with each cycle.

Of course, not all AI agents are created equally and many are just glorified chatbots. So, investors need to be analyze the market closely and be very selecting when investment in AI Agent tokens.

By February 20, 2025, AI agent tokens hit a $7 billion market cap (CoinGecko), with forecasts eyeing $40 billion in five years. They’re not just tools—they’re becoming economic players, holding wallets, driving trends, and reshaping crypto’s narrative. Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong predicts “hundreds of millions” of agents, while Crypto.com’s Eric Anziani sees “trillions of transactions” on-chain. Posts on X hype them as “the future of trading,” flagging scams or minting memecoins in seconds.

Until today, AI Agents mostly traded on decentralized exchanges and were not able to secure listings on major centralized exchanges. But Coinbase just listed Bittensor (TAO) and the token is up 22% in the past week alone. Bittensor is an open-source protocol that utilizes blockchain technology to create a decentralized machine learning network. It is the largest market cap token focused on AI in the crypto sector, but is still not well understood. Bittensor’s vision for a decentralized AI company has captivated a large number of people in the arenas of Artificial Intelligence and computer science, who have yearned for an alternative to the top-down world being created by our current technology giants.

At Nicoya Research, we think there is significant upside ahead for TAO over the next 6 months. But we also hold a number of smaller-cap AI plays that are more focused on the development of AI agents. Most of these tokens had a massive runs higher at the end of 2024 and into January of 2025. Many of these tokens that we hold or track increased 10x or more in value during that time period, but have since given back most of those gains. This dip following the initial mania might provide investors that missed the first explosive move higher with another opportunity to buy at oversold valuations.

Conclusion: A Reckoning Looms

Memecoins are a double-edged sword. They’ve injected energy and users into crypto, but the cost is steep: distorted markets, rampant scams, regulatory risk, destabilizing volatility, and a tarnished mission. The $100 billion memecoin market of 2024 may grow “crazier,” as Khan predicts, but bubbles burst. When they do, the fallout could stall crypto’s progress for years. Investors should tread carefully—blockchain tracks every move—and the industry must refocus on substance over memes.

A better alternative for cryptocurrency investors may be in Artificial Intelligence Agents that run on blockchains and have access to capital (crypto) to actually generate value in the real world. This generated value can be returned to token holders. Taking it a step further, AI Agents have the potential to free humanity from monotonous busy work and allow more free time to pursue true passions during our short trip on this planet. There is upside to humanity in their development, which is more than can be said about the current memecoin craze.

More By This Author: