I chose not to buy NVIDIA (NVDA) under Jensen Huang. A brilliant innovator and visionary, absolutely. But operationally, I distrusted and therefore avoided what I considered cleverness, yes, but also trickery. I would not play The Circle Game.
For those SA readers unfamiliar with this game, take a look at the photo above. The way it has worked is that NVIDIA wants to find new markets for its chips. So, NVIDIA buys shares in or lends money to an AI company, some well-established, others smaller, that looks as if it will grow into a major buyer. Those companies, large and small, typically build data centers or do greater research, begin to run out of chips essential to their continued growth, etc., and, voila! Yes, they need chips. Grateful for the boost, they buy NVIDIA's chips, NVIDIA records the sales, and everybody in the circle sings Kumbaya.
Sometimes there is an extra link in the chain, like when NVIDIA made a good-sized investment in CoreWeave (CRWV), which then bought NVIDIA chips and rented compute capacity to OpenAI and others—with NVIDIA agreeing to buy some of CoreWeave's excess capacity if it couldn't sell all the chips.
There is nothing illegal about this. NVIDIA fully reports all of these transactions, and there is no formal written agreement that forces the recipients of this largesse to buy from NVIDIA. It is not illegal. But I find it slick.
I don't want to be slick. It is too smarmy.
My concern has been that The Circle Game can make demand look stronger for NVIDIA. If AI customers can't keep growing at a stellar rate, they will likely reduce further orders or stop buying entirely. In that case, NVIDIA loses twice, while the others lose only once. NVIDIA could then see weaker chip sales but also losses on their investments and guarantees.
I don't want my technology companies playing the stock market, no matter what wunderkind is running the company.
NBC News created this graphic in October 2025. The incestuous circle has only grown since then.
Graphic: Rob Wile, Melinda Yao and Joe Murphy / NBC News
As long as AI valuations keep moving "to Infinity and Beyond!" (regards to Buzz Lightyear) and as long as investors keep buying no matter the cost, there is no problem.
So Why Am I Buying NVIDIA Now?
Regime change. NVIDIA and the entire AI industry needed men with great vision to bring us to this point. But visionaries and circularity can stumble. I want a CEO at NVIDIA that looks at the balance sheet
When a company gets this big, I prefer a CEO with a razor-sharp focus on the bottom line. I want one that knows how to execute, having done so already at a similar level.
Someone with the kind of judgment that is not distracted from a clear direction, someone who knows business and where to find and hire the best people. I want someone who hires innovators, seers, and gurus but is himself or herself a financial whiz who understands risk management, with an eagle eye on the balance sheet, profit and loss, cash flow, sales flow and understands they must hire brilliant operational executives alongside the gurus.
Jensen Huang chose to fill both roles, but there is no way he could have kept it up. The reason for his dismissal as CEO is unfortunate, and he may yet have an important role to play at NVIDIA or any other company in the business. But NVIDIA is now too big to handle by a single guru/CEO.
Who Might Be Sought As CEO For NVIDIA?
Your guess is as good as mine. But some names come to me as possibilities:
The Very Long Shot would be Tim Cook, former CEO of Apple (AAPL). He is now Apple's executive chairman, so it would seem he is ensconced there happily. Still, for a chance to build another Leviathan now under a question mark? Tempting.
Perhaps John Donahoe, who led Nike, eBay, and ServiceNow (and before that was CEO of Bain.) That is some significant Big Boy leadership experience.
Maybe Meg Whitman. Former CEO of eBay and HP/HPE (Disclosure: I own a significant position in HPE.) She had a consequential Big Girl experience leading large-scale transformative businesses. She is currently Albertsons' executive chair, but who knows? She recently sold her Spring Creek Ranch, a beautiful 1,500-acre property near Redding, CA. (I travel extensively and happened to see it coming out of the mountains—from a distance only!) Maybe she'd like to spend more time in urban environs.
Laxman Narasimhan comes to mind. As former CEO of Starbucks and Reckitt, he now serves on various large-cap boards. Maybe he would consider this challenge.
I'm sure my steadfast readers will come up with other ideas. I welcome your thoughts!
Risks
Besides everything I have said above (my analysis is all about risk!), there is always the risk that the entire AI balloon pops. My largest tech holdings today are two cybersecurity firms. There are so many cases, and I imagine some that are known to the insiders but may not see the light of day, where AI has turned rogue. Those in the business will say, "No sweat. We are new at this, and we will solve it." I wonder if Isaac Asimov (I, Robot, etc.) would agree.
I received my first BB gun at the age of 10 and my first .22 at 12. But I was not allowed to use either of them until my dad, an expert marksman and range safety person, thoroughly drilled me on weapon safety. Maybe some of the AI entrepreneurs should slow this march down until they learn the same skills. To many, AI is not a boundless money machine; it is adult kids playing with dangerous weapons without training.
I do not believe that citizen concerns over data center invasions in their neighborhoods are as serious a risk as some believe. The builders of data centers will simply go to regions, states, and counties with sparser populations and build there. But it is a risk that they may be "somewhat" slowed down.
Owning NVIDIA
What I now own, at today's price, is a company that has retreated from a high of $239 per share five weeks ago and is now on sale for $162. It enjoys a forward PE estimate of less than 18 and even now enjoys a market cap of $4 trillion.
Seeking Alpha
If it declines further, I will buy more. And to not miss out if a new CEO is found that gives Wall Street and investors warm fuzzies, I have a buy-stop order only a few dollars above the current price.
Disclosure:
I/we have a beneficial long position in the shares of NVDA either through stock ownership, options, or other derivatives. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
Disclaimer:
Unless you are a client of my portfolio management firm, Stanford Wealth Management, I do not know your personal financial situation. Therefore, I offer my opinions above for your due diligence and not as advice to buy or sell specific securities.
Comments
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.