The 3-Big Lies About Tax Cuts & The Economic Impact

“The greatest trick the Devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn’t exist.” – The Usual Suspects (1995)

Just recently, Politico ran a story by Brain Faler entitled: “Big Businesses Paying Even Less Than Expected Under GOP Law.” To wit:

“The U.S. Treasury saw a 31 percent drop in corporate tax revenues last year, almost twice the decline official budget forecasters had predicted. Receipts were projected to rebound sharply this year, but so far they’ve only continued to fall, down by almost 9 percent or $11 billion.

Though business profits remain healthy and the economy is strong, total corporate taxes are at the lowest levels seen in more than 50 years. Analysts agree they can’t yet explain the decline in corporate tax payments.

Uhm, excuse me?

This is where I get to say, “I Told You So!”

The Big Lie #1

While the Devil may have convinced the world he doesn’t exist, it was that “corporate cronyism” devoured Washington politics.

“Our companies won’t be leaving our country any longer because our tax burden is so high.” – Donald Trump 

That was an outright lie.

First of all, there is a massive difference between “statutory,” the stated tax rate, and the “effective” tax rate, or what companies actually pay. The chart below shows corporate profits before and after-tax with a measure of what the effective tax rate was.

 

Just prior to the passage of the tax cut bill, the effective tax rate for U.S. companies was about 16%, or less than half of the statutory rate of 35%. After the passage of the legislation, the effective tax rate fell to 11%, again less than half of the statutory rate of 21%.

There is also the matter that every other country in the world has a “value-added tax,” or VAT, added to their corporate tax rate. Dr. John Hussman did a good piece of analysis on this.

“I’ll add that another feature of Wall Street’s blissful delusion is the notion that ‘U.S. corporate taxes are the highest in the world.’ It’s striking how disingenuous this claim is. The fact is that among all OECD countries, the U.S. is also the only country that does not levy any tax at all on corporate value-added in the production of goods and services.”

 

“The main point is this. The argument that U.S. taxes on corporate profits are somehow oppressive relative to other countries is an apples-to-oranges comparison. It wholly ignores that the U.S. levies no value-added tax on corporations at all, whereas the value-added tax is the principal revenue source for most other countries. The rhetoric on corporate taxes here is unfiltered effluvium.

It is a myth that the U.S. has the highest corporate tax rate in the world. We simply didn’t, and don’t.

1 2 3 4
View single page >> |
How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience. Users' ratings are only visible to themselves.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.