Recent Changes In S&P 500 Betas - December 2017
A lot of modern equity theories and research is based on Betas or how individual stock movements relate to the underlying stock index. But much of the data is "dirty" or at best unreliable for basing investment decisions on. As noted in a previous article, betas for individual stocks can diverge quite significantly compared to the index over even the medium-term lengths. This opens the possibility that while individual investors can be basing their decisions on this data, the stocks they are considering can be greatly diverging from the norms. This post highlights some lists of stocks that are high beta stocks, low beta or negative beta, and stocks that have high percentage change in their respective beta.
The betas are derived from closing prices over the last quarter with at least 50 market days of data. Instead of data over the last 5 years assuming monthly returns (as others seem to be using), the analysis below is looking at short-term data and changes over the quarter compared to the last quarter. Betas for individual stocks can vary broadly over the long term (such as 5 years) and thus will not recognize either convergence or divergence from correlation with the market. Thus, any investor relying on outdated data may be greatly disappointed by changes in the betas in their portfolio by either experiencing higher volatility or lower than expected returns compared to the market.
TICKER |
Name |
beta |
Std_Error |
(NASDAQ: WLTW) | WILLIS TOWERS WATSON PUB LTD CO | 0.247805 | 0.263009 |
(NASDAQ: NI) | NISOURCE INC COM | 0.244255 | 0.354138 |
(NASDAQ: PPL) | PPL CORP COM | 0.243165 | 0.36112 |
(NASDAQ: COO) | COOPER COS INC COM NEW | 0.237812 | 0.525662 |
(NASDAQ: AMZN) | AMAZON COM INC | 0.228598 | 0.661318 |
(NASDAQ: ADSK) | AUTODESK INC | 0.214303 | 0.783888 |
(NASDAQ: VTR) | VENTAS INC COM | 0.187647 | 0.352189 |
(NASDAQ: CCI) | CROWN CASTLE INTL CORP NEW COM | 0.17901 | 0.394732 |
(NASDAQ: AES) | AES CORP COM | 0.176139 | 0.427233 |
(NASDAQ: NEM) | NEWMONT MNG CORP COM | 0.17029 | 0.403181 |
(NASDAQ: AVY) | AVERY DENNISON CORP COM | 0.155904 | 0.394736 |
(NASDAQ: ORCL) | ORACLE CORP COM | 0.155378 | 0.335958 |
(NASDAQ: SPG) | SIMON PPTY GROUP INC NEW COM | 0.1383 | 0.463468 |
(NYSE: EFC) | ELLINGTON FINL LLC COM | 0.136053 | 0.19864 |
(Pacifi: JNJ) | JOHNSON & JOHNSON COM | 0.126014 | 0.262726 |
(NASDAQ: NKE) | NIKE INC CL B | 0.11718 | 0.413574 |
(NASDAQ: PG) | PROCTER & GAMBLE CO COM | 0.113999 | 0.274884 |
(NASDAQ: XRAY) | DENTSPLY SIRONA INC | 0.087326 | 0.514971 |
(NASDAQ: PSA) | PUBLIC STORAGE COM | 0.055567 | 0.325159 |
(NASDAQ: STZ) | CONSTELLATION BRANDS INC CL A | 0.054524 | 0.330243 |
(NASDAQ: SBUX) | STARBUCKS CORP | 0.04289 | 0.317975 |
(NASDAQ: D) | DOMINION RES INC VA NEW COM | 0.034592 | 0.276617 |
(NASDAQ: O) | REALTY INCOME CORP COM | 0.034527 | 0.299957 |
(NASDAQ: QCOM) | QUALCOMM INC | 0.02688 | 0.766136 |
(NASDAQ: RE) | EVEREST RE GROUP COM | 0.019874 | 0.475939 |
(NASDAQ: NEE) | NEXTERA ENERGY INC COM | 0.014398 | 0.278498 |
(NASDAQ: MU) | MICRON TECHNOLOGY INC | 0.00097 | 0.925099 |
(NASDAQ: LARK) | LANDMARK BANCORP INC | -0.00333 | 0.540531 |
(NASDAQ: TOT) | TOTAL S A SPONSORED ADR | -0.01451 | 0.269694 |
(NASDAQ: DLR) | DIGITAL RLTY TR INC COM | -0.05394 | 0.556604 |
(NASDAQ: PEP) | PEPSICO INC | -0.06198 | 0.259889 |
(Pacifi: DUK) | DUKE ENERGY CORP NEW COM NEW | -0.11802 | 0.245172 |
(NASDAQ: SO) | SOUTHERN CO COM | -0.19591 | 0.290411 |
(NASDAQ: BSX) | BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP COM | -0.22538 | 0.504566 |
(NASDAQ: KO) | COCA COLA CO COM | -0.31447 | 0.236411 |
(NASDAQ: SBAC) | SBA COMMUNICATIONS CORP NEW | -0.3259 | 0.544618 |
(NASDAQ: TESS) | TESSCO TECHNOLOGIES INC | -0.43902 | 1.141962 |
(NASDAQ: CELG) | CELGENE CORP | -0.79473 | 0.963716 |
(NASDAQ: MAT) | MATTEL INC | -1.16034 | 1.468971 |
The above table shows the lowest betas including negative ones along with the standard errors of the betas derived from the linear regressions. This shows that while there a few negative betas, but none are significantly different than zero. Specifically, that means that the true beta could easily be with-in the range of zero. While that would negate the positive aspects of negative betas, it does provide stocks that are not reacting to the market forces and thus can reduce market risks. But conversely it does reduce idiosyncratic risks of the individual stocks.
The next table shows the highest beta stocks in the sample. A portfolio composed of those stocks would basically be a multiplier of 2 times the market. This is great for up markets, but down markets drive the portfolio 2 times the market loss. Other investors might find value in shorting such stocks as it would take less percentage of the portfolio for the same level of hedging.
TICKER |
Name |
beta |
Std_Error |
(NASDAQ: AYI) | ACUITY BRANDS INC COM | 2.802731 | 0.597176 |
(NASDAQ: MLM) | MARTIN MARIETTA MATLS INC COM | 2.726661 | 0.458947 |
(Pacifi: ALK) | ALASKA AIR GROUP INC COM | 2.699265 | 0.747045 |
(NASDAQ: UAA) | UNDER ARMOUR INC CL A | 2.678781 | 1.326456 |
(NASDAQ: DISCK) | DISCOVERY COMMUNICATIONS INC NEW | 2.605426 | 0.888987 |
(NASDAQ: URI) | UNITED RENTALS INC COM | 2.520355 | 0.379382 |
(: CTL) | CENTURYLINK INC COM | 2.503713 | 1.013836 |
(NASDAQ: UA) | UNDER ARMOUR INC CL C | 2.495766 | 1.292713 |
(NASDAQ: CMG) | CHIPOTLE MEXICAN GRILL INC NEW COM | 2.447678 | 0.866462 |
(NASDAQ: DISCA) | DISCOVERY COMMUNICATIONS INC NEW | 2.428246 | 0.863097 |
(NASDAQ: AMD) | ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES INC | 2.322154 | 1.022298 |
(Pacifi: TGT) | TARGET CORP COM | 2.295715 | 0.77229 |
(NASDAQ: ADS) | ALLIANCE DATA SYS CORP COM | 2.265018 | 0.407083 |
(NASDAQ: TRIP) | TRIPADVISOR INC | 2.261516 | 1.225554 |
(NASDAQ: SYF) | SYNCHRONY FINL COM | 2.224273 | 0.424387 |
(NASDAQ: KR) | KROGER CO COM | 2.217169 | 0.558426 |
(M) | MACYS INC COM | 2.194347 | 0.959631 |
(NASDAQ: KSS) | KOHLS CORP COM | 2.187844 | 0.610637 |
(NASDAQ: AAP) | ADVANCED AUTO PTS INC COM | 2.159047 | 1.007731 |
(NASDAQ: VMC) | VULCAN MATLS CO COM | 2.158158 | 0.459932 |
(NASDAQ: PWR) | QUANTA SERVICES INC COM | 2.155215 | 0.378715 |
(NASDAQ: BRKL) | BROOKLINE BANCORP INC DEL | 2.14183 | 0.391747 |
(NASDAQ: RHI) | ROBERT HALF INTL INC COM | 2.108334 | 0.448139 |
(Pacifi: NUE) | NUCOR CORP COM | 2.075359 | 0.408075 |
(NASDAQ: NTAP) | NETAPP INC | 2.045434 | 0.735238 |
(NASDAQ: MAS) | MASCO CORP COM | 2.021558 | 0.282767 |
(NASDAQ: NFX) | NEWFIELD EXPL CO COM | 2.021302 | 0.851287 |
(NASDAQ: RRC) | RANGE RES CORP COM | 1.980926 | 0.830647 |
(NASDAQ: DOV) | DOVER CORP COM | 1.968819 | 0.372279 |
(NASDAQ: CHK) | CHESAPEAKE ENERGY CORP COM | 1.959001 | 1.099974 |
(NASDAQ: JWN) | NORDSTROM INC COM | 1.941566 | 0.690207 |
(NASDAQ: JEC) | JACOBS ENGR GROUP INC COM | 1.939014 | 0.485223 |
(Pacifi: IR) | INGERSOLL-RAND PLC ORD | 1.929163 | 0.364479 |
(NASDAQ: CVS) | CVS HEALTH CORP COM | 1.926955 | 0.626239 |
(NASDAQ: ZION) | ZIONS BANCORPORATION | 1.915474 | 0.418932 |
(NASDAQ: SCHW) | SCHWAB CHARLES CORP NEW COM | 1.8933 | 0.384708 |
(COST) | COSTCO WHSL CORP NEW | 1.862581 | 0.397058 |
(NASDAQ: NSC) | NORFOLK SOUTHN CORP COM | 1.846293 | 0.363883 |
(NASDAQ: FCX) | FREEPORT-MCMORAN INC COM | 1.837058 | 0.651899 |
(NASDAQ: FCX) | FREEPORT-MCMORAN INC COM | 1.837058 | 0.651899 |
(: ALB) | ALBEMARLE CORP COM | 1.813328 | 0.48111 |
(NASDAQ: CFG) | CITIZENS FINL GROUP INC COM | 1.80757 | 0.405879 |
(NASDAQ: HP) | HELMERICH & PAYNE INC COM | 1.789157 | 0.604989 |
(NASDAQ: AOS) | SMITH A O CORP COM | 1.77919 | 0.262316 |
(: EIX) | EDISON INTL COM | 1.774727 | 0.768031 |
(NASDAQ: CMA) | COMERICA INC COM | 1.760298 | 0.365967 |
(Pacifi: LUV) | SOUTHWEST AIRLS CO COM | 1.743631 | 0.460176 |
(NASDAQ: PCAR) | PACCAR INC | 1.735012 | 0.432694 |
(NASDAQ: IPG) | INTERPUBLIC GROUP COS INC COM | 1.731109 | 0.52809 |
(NASDAQ: JBHT) | HUNT J B TRANS SVCS INC | 1.730553 | 0.451075 |
(NASDAQ: ARNC) | ARCONIC INC COM | 1.724111 | 0.649587 |
(NASDAQ: DLTR) | DOLLAR TREE INC | 1.722254 | 0.359549 |
(NASDAQ: ORLY) | O REILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC NEW | 1.721755 | 0.613698 |
(NASDAQ: HPE) | HEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE CO COM | 1.716345 | 0.614181 |
(NASDAQ: STI) | SUNTRUST BKS INC COM | 1.711734 | 0.34543 |
(: MS) | MORGAN STANLEY COM NEW | 1.706439 | 0.273591 |
(NASDAQ: TXT) | TEXTRON INC COM | 1.703999 | 0.255015 |
(NASDAQ: DFS) | DISCOVER FINL SVCS COM | 1.703672 | 0.356442 |
(: KEY) | KEYCORP NEW COM | 1.681543 | 0.351228 |
(NASDAQ: PDCO) | PATTERSON COMPANIES INC | 1.646097 | 0.671337 |
(: UNP) | UNION PAC CORP COM | 1.638034 | 0.407957 |
(NASDAQ: UAL) | UNITED CONTL HLDGS INC COM | 1.628793 | 0.715846 |
(NASDAQ: AMG) | AFFILIATED MANAGERS GRP INC COM | 1.626314 | 0.256302 |
(NASDAQ: SNA) | SNAP ON INC COM | 1.61193 | 0.32989 |
(NASDAQ: COF) | CAPITAL ONE FINL CORP COM | 1.607855 | 0.354545 |
(NASDAQ: SJM) | SMUCKER J M CO COM NEW | 1.604849 | 0.574894 |
(NASDAQ: UHS) | UNIVERSAL HEALTH SVCS INC CL B | 1.603839 | 0.503747 |
The next two tables show the biggest percentage gains and declines in betas respectively. The two time periods have at least 50 market days before December 25th and October 27th for 2017 for each stock. The tables also include the latest values for beta and the standard errors for the betas. As stated earlier, betas can and do change over time, thus it behooves investors to keep a watch on the betas of stocks in their portfolios.
TICKER |
Name |
% Change in Beta |
beta |
Std_Error |
(NASDAQ: CNP) | CENTERPOINT ENERGY INC COM | 4630% | 0.388687254 | 0.300595101 |
(NASDAQ: AEE) | AMEREN CORP COM | 1617% | 0.310325368 | 0.309018138 |
(: EIX) | EDISON INTL COM | 1149% | 1.774727326 | 0.768031063 |
(NASDAQ: RCKY) | ROCKY BRANDS INC | 873% | 1.069680776 | 1.196457607 |
(NASDAQ: SJM) | SMUCKER J M CO COM NEW | 514% | 1.604849101 | 0.574893863 |
(NASDAQ: K) | KELLOGG CO COM | 425% | 0.678354533 | 0.498294916 |
(NASDAQ: JBHT) | HUNT J B TRANS SVCS INC | 404% | 1.730553463 | 0.451074642 |
(NASDAQ: ORLY) | O REILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC NEW | 371% | 1.721754646 | 0.613697792 |
(NASDAQ: CHRW) | C H ROBINSON WORLDWIDE INC | 336% | 1.572651689 | 0.340105723 |
(NASDAQ: CBS) | CBS CORP NEW CL B | 311% | 0.853650734 | 0.541382459 |
(NASDAQ: SNI) | SCRIPPS NETWORKS INTERACTIVE INC | 304% | 0.869379032 | 0.282978541 |
(NASDAQ: KORS) | MICHAEL KORS HOLDINGS LTD. ORD | 270% | 1.465446313 | 0.712108875 |
(NASDAQ: UAA) | UNDER ARMOUR INC CL A | 244% | 2.678780787 | 1.326455719 |
(NASDAQ: HRB) | BLOCK H & R INC COM | 240% | 0.543979449 | 0.810387337 |
(NASDAQ: SRE) | SEMPRA ENERGY COM | 238% | 0.265525517 | 0.390291911 |
(NASDAQ: KIM) | KIMCO RLTY CORP COM | 237% | 0.76868828 | 0.484294305 |
(NASDAQ: DISCK) | DISCOVERY COMMUNICATIONS INC NEW | 234% | 2.605426308 | 0.888986867 |
(: SLB) | SCHLUMBERGER LTD COM | 227% | 1.18472958 | 0.501140692 |
(NASDAQ: CLX) | CLOROX CO COM | 217% | 0.317720228 | 0.333718989 |
(NASDAQ: TWX) | TIME WARNER INC NEW COM NEW | 216% | 1.054895609 | 0.464481527 |
(NASDAQ: VTR) | VENTAS INC COM | 198% | 0.187647485 | 0.352188839 |
(NASDAQ: SYY) | SYSCO CORP COM | 196% | 1.057471372 | 0.389628667 |
(NASDAQ: TRIP) | TRIPADVISOR INC | 191% | 2.261516055 | 1.225553863 |
(NASDAQ: DISCA) | DISCOVERY COMMUNICATIONS INC NEW | 175% | 2.4282458 | 0.8630968 |
(NASDAQ: HUM) | HUMANA INC COM | 172% | 1.053974359 | 0.487624956 |
(NASDAQ: NOV) | NATIONAL OILWELL VARCO INC COM | 163% | 1.457134717 | 0.539909834 |
(NASDAQ: APC) | ANADARKO PETE CORP COM | 161% | 0.890435338 | 0.467291319 |
(: PXD) | PIONEER NAT RES CO COM | 159% | 1.364092391 | 0.558311131 |
(NASDAQ: CI) | CIGNA CORP COM | 159% | 1.427788743 | 0.358765671 |
(NASDAQ: PWR) | QUANTA SERVICES INC COM | 156% | 2.155214548 | 0.378715338 |
(NASDAQ: CVS) | CVS HEALTH CORP COM | 155% | 1.926955037 | 0.626239099 |
(NASDAQ: VIAB) | VIACOM INC NEW | 152% | 1.280651564 | 0.876854624 |
(NASDAQ: UA) | UNDER ARMOUR INC CL C | 145% | 2.495766063 | 1.292713278 |
(Pacifi: TGT) | TARGET CORP COM | 143% | 2.295715181 | 0.772290094 |
(NASDAQ: JWN) | NORDSTROM INC COM | 141% | 1.941566393 | 0.690207214 |
(NASDAQ: CAG) | CONAGRA FOODS INC COM | 141% | 0.928243167 | 0.372172783 |
(NASDAQ: MYL) | MYLAN N V | 133% | 1.222168595 | 0.954047187 |
(NASDAQ: AVB) | AVALONBAY CMNTYS INC COM | 131% | 0.396302907 | 0.266334425 |
(NASDAQ: VZ) | VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC COM | 129% | 1.454601378 | 0.362513008 |
(NASDAQ: RHI) | ROBERT HALF INTL INC COM | 127% | 2.10833415 | 0.448139177 |
(NASDAQ: RTN) | RAYTHEON CO COM NEW | 127% | 0.692589733 | 0.306370255 |
(NASDAQ: MLM) | MARTIN MARIETTA MATLS INC COM | 124% | 2.7266606 | 0.458947183 |
(NASDAQ: DLTR) | DOLLAR TREE INC | 122% | 1.722254276 | 0.359548548 |
(NASDAQ: BXP) | BOSTON PROPERTIES INC COM | 121% | 0.45707922 | 0.302385943 |
(: COST) | COSTCO WHSL CORP NEW | 119% | 1.862581037 | 0.397057637 |
(NASDAQ: ARE) | ALEXANDRIA REAL ESTATE EQUITIES INC COM | 118% | 0.716023259 | 0.289191239 |
(: STX) | SEAGATE TECHNOLOGY PLC | 116% | 0.920338023 | 0.744118672 |
(NASDAQ: SNA) | SNAP ON INC COM | 108% | 1.611929785 | 0.329890413 |
(: MRK) | MERCK & CO INC NEW COM | 107% | 1.28903591 | 0.43023123 |
(NASDAQ: WMT) | WAL MART STORES INC COM | 106% | 0.920503376 | 0.561784431 |
(NASDAQ: HP) | HELMERICH & PAYNE INC COM | 102% | 1.789156501 | 0.604988742 |
(NASDAQ: DVN) | DEVON ENERGY CORP NEW COM | 100% | 1.336683832 | 0.610017227 |
TICKER |
Name |
% Change in Beta |
beta |
Std_Error |
(NASDAQ: AIV) | APARTMENT INVT & MGMT CO CL A | -806% | 0.553497286 | 0.278762399 |
(NASDAQ: PEG) | PUBLIC SVC ENTERPRISE GROUP INC COM | -790% | 0.313135889 | 0.234217041 |
(NASDAQ: PNW) | PINNACLE WEST CAP CORP COM | -670% | 0.479740965 | 0.294610326 |
(NASDAQ: CMS) | CMS ENERGY CORP COM | -654% | 0.294034875 | 0.269505764 |
(NASDAQ: UDR) | UDR INC COM | -630% | 0.511893889 | 0.281217172 |
(NASDAQ: WEC) | WEC ENERGY GROUP INC COM | -527% | 0.309736753 | 0.266483508 |
(NASDAQ: CPB) | CAMPBELL SOUP CO COM | -423% | 1.448886593 | 0.681262719 |
(NASDAQ: DTE) | DTE ENERGY CO COM | -322% | 0.3184817 | 0.279496592 |
(NASDAQ: KO) | COCA COLA CO COM | -288% | -0.314468663 | 0.236411482 |
(NASDAQ: ED) | CONSOLIDATED EDISON HLDG INC COM | -273% | 0.323894101 | 0.257343404 |
(NASDAQ: PRGO) | PERRIGO COMPANY PLC ORD | -271% | 1.468209305 | 0.558153066 |
(Pacifi: AEP) | AMERICAN ELEC PWR INC COM | -268% | 0.31362047 | 0.256199846 |
(NASDAQ: XEL) | XCEL ENERGY INC COM | -253% | 0.285173971 | 0.265443202 |
(NASDAQ: PPL) | PPL CORP COM | -215% | 0.243165212 | 0.361120419 |
(NASDAQ: MAT) | MATTEL INC | -210% | -1.160344248 | 1.468971107 |
(NASDAQ: SO) | SOUTHERN CO COM | -209% | -0.195908156 | 0.290411224 |
(NASDAQ: CELG) | CELGENE CORP | -180% | -0.794725568 | 0.963716213 |
(NASDAQ: SBAC) | SBA COMMUNICATIONS CORP NEW | -170% | -0.325899416 | 0.544618253 |
(NASDAQ: TESS) | TESSCO TECHNOLOGIES INC | -150% | -0.439022293 | 1.141961911 |
(NASDAQ: NEM) | NEWMONT MNG CORP COM | -147% | 0.170290496 | 0.403181359 |
(NASDAQ: D) | DOMINION RES INC VA NEW COM | -132% | 0.034592268 | 0.276616648 |
(NASDAQ: BSX) | BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP COM | -130% | -0.225383406 | 0.504566027 |
(NASDAQ: PEP) | PEPSICO INC | -123% | -0.061979622 | 0.25988902 |
(NASDAQ: PSA) | PUBLIC STORAGE COM | -121% | 0.055566957 | 0.32515885 |
(NASDAQ: DLR) | DIGITAL RLTY TR INC COM | -105% | -0.053936931 | 0.556603523 |
(NASDAQ: TOT) | TOTAL S A SPONSORED ADR | -103% | -0.014514435 | 0.269693943 |
(NASDAQ: LARK) | LANDMARK BANCORP INC | -102% | -0.003329924 | 0.540530655 |
(NASDAQ: MU) | MICRON TECHNOLOGY INC | -100% | 0.000970342 | 0.92509913 |
Lists like the ones above could be used to discover stocks that balance market risks or even create portfolios like the single index model or risk budgeting for efficient portfolios. If any of the information and data was useful or interesting, I would love to hear from you. I hope that everyone that finds the information interesting to express what they like or what areas could be expanded and improved upon.
Since investors have different time frames for the investment decisions, a tool like this could provide betas over daily, weekly, monthly, or even quarterly by entering the stocks to watch.