Single Family Housing Transactions Have Crashed, But When Will That Matter?

Let's take a look at the relationship between single family housing construction, employment, and GDP.

(Click on image to enlarge)

Quarterly averages of housing construction and private residential fixed investment 

Quarterly averages of housing construction and private residential fixed investment 

 

Housing Construction vs Private Fixed Investment Notes

  • It's more than a bit unusual to plot thousands of units and billions of dollars on the same axis, but the chart conveys the important ideas. 
  • Single family construction is far more important than total units under construction.
  • Private Residential Fixed Investment, a component of GDP follows single family with a lag that might be quite long.

 

Private Residential Housing Units vs Private Residential Fixed Investment 

(Click on image to enlarge)

Private Residential Housing Units vs Private Residential Fixed Investment Revised 2022-24

The second chart is the same as the first except that I added a line for multi-family, 5 or more units in a single building.

Total units under construction is still rising but private residential fixed construction is falling. Why is that?

My charts above are quarterly charts. Let's hone in on employment, the subject of my previous post, Idea of the Day: Construction Employment Saved the Economy But That's Now Ending

I created some new charts to better highlight what's happening.

 

Private Residential Housing vs Residential Building Employees Long Term

(Click on image to enlarge)

Housing starts and units under construction vs residential building employees - monthly numbers

Housing starts and units under construction vs residential building employees - monthly numbers

Once again I have an unusual left axis (thousands of units or thousands of employees), but again it ties everything together nicely.

The lags are considerable. Starts turn lower first while total units under construction flattens. Single family units under construction lags starts, and residential building employment tends to lag everything. 

The dashed blue lines are examples of the preceding paragraph. 

I prefer to use starts rather than permits because starts eventually gets finished, but permits may not result in starts for very long periods at turns. 

 

Private Residential Housing vs Residential Building Employees Short Term

(Click on image to enlarge)

Private RTesidential Housing vs Residential Building Employees 2023-01

With total housing units flatlining and single family units under construction falling pretty hard, it's likely that residential housing employment is poised to fall. 

The rate of decline in employment will depend on how fast the units under construction finish. 

 

No Rebound in Existing Home Sales Despite a Drop in Mortgage Rates

(Click on image to enlarge)

Existing-Home Sales 2023-01

Meanwhile, please note No Rebound in Existing Home Sales Despite a Drop in Mortgage Rates

That matters too. Employment is not just a matter of new construction but also remodeling.

 

30-Year Mortgage Rates 

(Click on image to enlarge)

30-year mortgage rates courtesy of Mortgage News Daily. 

30-year mortgage rates courtesy of Mortgage News Daily. 

 

Median Home Prices Fall for First Time in a Decade, But What Does It Mean?

On March 4, I asked Median Home Prices Fall for First Time in a Decade, But What Does It Mean?

People are pulling listings. With falling housing prices and slumping listings, remodeling work is also falling.

So is demand for appliances, furniture, landscaping etc. But with the service sector still humming (for now), Powell's Hawkish Speech to Congress Sends Interest Rate Hike Odds Soaring

And mortgage rates are back above 7.0 percent. Who wants to trade a mortgage below 3.0 percent for a 7.0 percent mortgage. 

 

Senator Elizabeth Warren Confronts Jerome Powell But She's Not Worried About Inflation

Politically speaking, no matter whether you agree or disagree Senator Elizabeth Warren Confronts Jerome Powell But She's Not Worried About Inflation

Finally, we all understand rate hikes act with a lag. None of us really know how big that lag is. 

But here we are, and another half-point hike now seems baked in the cake on March 22. 

Good luck with that.


More By This Author:

The Fed Chair Puts A Spotlight On Rent, Has Rent Really Stabilized?
Powell's Hawkish Speech To Congress Sends Interest Rate Hike Odds Soaring
A Fed Study Shows Loose Monetary Policy Leads To Disaster And Financial Crisis

Disclaimer: Click here to read the full disclaimer. 

How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.