Image Source: Unsplash

High-yield stocks pay out dividends that are significantly higher than the market average. For example, the S&P 500’s current yield is only ~1.2%.

High-yield stocks can be particularly beneficial in supplementing income after retirement. A $120,000 investment in stocks with an average dividend yield of 5% creates an average of $500 a month in dividends.

We have created a spreadsheet of stocks (and closely related REITs, MLPs, etc.) with dividend yields of 5% or more.

Next on our list of high-dividend stocks to review is Orchid Island Capital (ORC).

Business Overview

Orchid Island Capital, Inc. is a Real Estate Investment Trust, or REIT, operating in the mortgage industry. Mortgage REITs differ from most other REITs.

For example, traditional REITs typically own a portfolio of physical real estate, which they lease to tenants to collect rental income. Mortgage REITs are purely financial entities, and Orchid Island does not own any physical properties.

Instead, it is an externally managed REIT (by Bimini Advisors LLC) that invests in residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS), either pass-through or structured agency RMBSs, which are financial instruments that collect cash flow based on residential loans such as mortgages, including subprime, and home-equity loans.

On October 23, 2025, Orchid Island Capital, Inc. reported estimated net income of $0.53 per common share for Q3 2025, with book value per share estimated at $7.33 as of September 30, 2025.

The company declared a monthly dividend of $0.12 per share for October, keeping consistent with its monthly payout strategy. The RMBS portfolio and derivatives portfolio evolved as the company remained focused on agency residential mortgage-backed securities paired with hedging strategies.

Although full detail of realized and unrealized gains and losses was not yet publicly provided, the firm emphasized strong liquidity and modest leverage, reflecting its conservative balance sheet posture amid agency MBS market volatility.

Orchid Island highlighted that the investment backdrop remains attractive with improving spreads and prepayment risk manageable given the portfolio’s coupon distribution and hedges.

Growth Prospects

Orchid Island has experienced extreme earnings volatility over the past several years, along with multiple years in which the trust barely generated a profit.

As a result, we are using book value per share as an alternate metric to earnings-per-share. The growth outlook for mortgage REITs is challenged.

Mortgage REITs make money by borrowing at short-term rates and lending at longer-term rates, then pocketing the difference. This is referred to as the spread, which is how Orchid Capital generates its cash flow.

When the spread between short-term rates and long-term rates compresses, profitability erodes at a rapid pace. This is why mortgage REITs can be dangerous if the yield curve flattens.

Moving forward, we expect the book value per share to continue declining in the coming years and the high payout will result in weakening earnings per share and dividends per share.

Competitive Advantages & Recession Performance

Orchid Island is not a safe stock. Its payout ratios are extreme due to low or non-existent earnings. Mortgage REITs are exposed to a number of risks, including interest rate risk, as well as credit risk.

These risks pertain to the direction of interest rates, as well as the ability of borrowers to repay the mortgage loans. Moreover, mortgage REITs do not possess many competitive advantages.

Since mortgage REITs do not provide differentiated products and services, traditional competitive advantages such as brand power or manufacturing efficiencies do not apply.

In addition, Orchid Island is not a recession-resistant trust. A recession generally leads to higher mortgage defaults.

Dividend Analysis

Some investors may be enticed by the extremely high dividend yield for the stock, which drives the investment thesis. However, we offer two cautionary notes.

First, the dividend has already been cut multiple times since 2015.

Second, and just as important, is that despite an exceptionally high starting yield, total returns can be dampened significantly by the erosion in the share price as time goes on.

ORC is expected to generate earnings-per-share of $0.64 for 2025. This compares with a current annual dividend payout of $1.44 per share.

As a result, the expected dividend payout ratio is over 200% for 2025. This creates a risky situation, as the dividend is not covered by a long shot. Therefore, investors should consider the dividend payout to be unsustainable at the current level.

Final Thoughts

Orchid Island Capital offers an extremely attractive dividend yield. That said, it is an extremely risky stock due to its track record of consistently destroying shareholder capital and slashing its dividend repeatedly.

Given that the economy is facing growing risks and headwinds, we expect book value and dividend erosion in the coming years, and the payout ratio is very high as well. We therefore rate the stock as a sell.

More By This Author:

10 Low Payout Ratio Stocks With High Dividend Yields
10 Best Performing Dividend Kings Over The Last 10 Years
3 High Yield Stocks With Safe Dividends