This Is Why Japan Will Never Recover

Here’s a cheery headline to start the week: Japan 2014 births fall to lowest on record but deaths rise.

From the FT:

Deaths outnumbered births in Japan last year by the widest margin on record, underscoring the scale of the challenge facing the government as it tries to ensure a dwindling pool of workers can support growing ranks of pensioners.

The urgency of getting the country’s finances in order was highlighted this week as preliminary figures indicated that Japan’s population fell by a record 268,000 in 2014.

According to the data published by the ministry of health, labour and welfare, births slipped by 2.8 per cent to a low of 1m, while deaths rose fractionally to a high of 1.27m…

If the current nationwide fertility rate of 1.4 stays unchanged, a task force warned in November, then Japan’s population of 127m would drop by almost a third by 2060 and by two-thirds by 2110.

Even if the fertility rate were to rapidly rise to the replacement level of 2.07 by 2030 and then stay there, the population would keep falling for another 50 years before stabilising at a little less than 100m.

I tip my hat to Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe for at least making the effort to shake up Japan’s sluggish economy with his Abenomics reforms. But it won’t matter. Japan will never recover.

Try as he might, Abe can never be Japan’s Reagan or Thatcher. As sick as Britain and America were before the Reagan and Thatcher revolutions, the problems facing both countries were political. A politician with sufficient charisma–Reagan–or cojones–Thatcher–could have fixed them. But you can’t “fix” demographics with politics.

In a modern economy, consumer spending is the dominant contributor to GDP. But consumer spending requires consumers, and Japan has fewer of them every year. And the ones they do have are older and more inclined to save than spend.

Disclosure: Charles Lewis Sizemore, CFA, is the chief investment officer of the investment firm Sizemore Capital ...

more
How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.
Or Sign in with
Ferdinand E. Banks 10 years ago Contributor's comment

Somebody said something about the population problem in Japan. There is no population problem in Japan. There is a population problem in the U.S., and the correct name is overpopulation.

Ferdinand E. Banks 10 years ago Contributor's comment

Completely wrong. The Japanese have got what it takes to win, but unlike certain countries they don't play the hurry-hurry game. Of course, I admit that I didn't Think much of Reagan and Thatcher, although when I found out that Reagan did not want a war with Russia I changed my opinion of him.,

Ferdinand E. Banks 10 years ago Contributor's comment

Completely wrong. The Japanese have got what it takes to win, but unlike certain countries they don't play the hurry-hurry game. Of course, I admit that I didn't Think much of Reagan and Thatcher, although when I found out that Reagan did not want a war with Russia I changed my opinion of him.,

Ferdinand E. Banks 10 years ago Contributor's comment

Completely wrong. The Japanese have got what it takes to win, but unlike certain countries they don't play the hurry-hurry game. Of course, I admit that I didn't Think much of Reagan and Thatcher, although when I found out that Reagan did not want a war with Russia I changed my opinion of him.,

Moon Kil Woong 10 years ago Contributor's comment

The population problem is a function of having a 2 decade long economic decline in which the government has been part and parcel of and still decides to bury itself and their people into a bigger and bigger QE hole. There can be a recovery only after a massive QE collapse and a recognition one should accept reality instead of making it worse with socialism and mutated central bank money games. The same goes for the US which is still in denial and refusing to reform from the last downturn, consequently they are getting the ill effects of the QE bug as well starting with a distorted banking sector led by bigger TBTF banks and dependence on a government controlled false market through Fannie and Freddie.

Socialism and planned economics was the worst thing to immigrate to America in the last 10 years. They may call it anything else but that is what it is.