The Federal Reserve’s “Hawkishness” Finally Gets The Stock Market’s Attention

By Dr. Duru of Inflation Watch

Friday, December 20, 2024 2:10 AM EST

Bank Note, Euro, Bills, Paper Money

Image Source: Pixabay

Attention!

For three months, the bond market has flagged stabilizing inflation starting with the Fed’s first rate cut of 50 basis points (bps). The stock market continued to rally along its uptrend lines. In parallel, the Federal Reserve signaled its second thoughts about its benign projections for inflation in the September Summary of Economic Projections. The stock market failed to listen and even Fed fund futures insisted on forcing the Fed into a December rate cut. The Fed delivered that rate cut with a major caveat in the December Summary of Economic Projections: hotter forecasts for inflation and economic growth and an incrementally hawkish expectation for future monetary policy rates. Accordingly, the Fed finally got the stock market’s attention as the market essentially plunged from euphoria to oversold in one day.

Long-term yields continued to increase the day of the Fed decision and the following day. The iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT) sliced right through presumed support and closed right at the low for the year set in April.

I took profits on my latest round of TLT put options last week. I will not chase TLT down here. Instead, I will wait to fade the next relief rally.

Instructive Projections

The Fed’s changes were significant but consistent with the Fed’s smoke signals and the declines in the long-term bond market.

2025 PCE inflation of 2.3-2.6% vs. the 2.1-2.2% September projection
2025 federal funds rate of 3.6-4.1% vs. the 3.1-3.6% September projection
2025 GDP 1.8-2.2% vs. the September projection of 1.8-2.2%

Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s commentary during the press conference was instructive. Powell left no question that the Fed sees higher inflation ahead: “these median projections are somewhat higher than in September consistent with the firmer inflation projection.” He acknowledged that under-estimating inflation this year was a partial driver of higher 2025 expectations: this year’s projections have “fallen apart as we’ve approached the end of the year”. Yet, Powell also laid the foundation and rationale for keeping a bias toward easing. He pointed reiterated that the labor market is no longer contributing to inflationary pressures and its accompanying cooling has gone far enough. Moreover, activity in the housing sector has been “weak”. Accordingly, Powell claimed that “cuts will certainly help to support economic activity and the labor market while we can still make progress on inflation because policy is still meaningfully restrictive.”

I remain skeptical. Is current policy really “meaningfully restrictive”? In his opening statement, Powell declared “with today’s action we have lowered our policy rate by a full percentage point from its peak and our policy stance is now significantly less restrictive. We can therefore be more cautious as we consider further adjustments to our policy rate.” This claim only weakly translates into “meaningfully restrictive.” Moreover, financial conditions are now almost as loose as they have ever been since the pandemic per the Chicago Fed’s Adjusted National Financial Conditions Index (ANFCI).

Sure, as one reporter in the Q&A pointed out, “we haven’t seen much change in mortgages, auto loan rates, or credit card rates.” Still, the conventional measures of financial conditions are about as good as can be in the post-pandemic era. Thus, the Fed is walking a fine line between the fear of restoking firmer than expected inflation and a labor market that is noticeably cooling. In the middle, the stock market is pricing in a perfect resolution to this dilemma even with the current plunge.

Powell’s Inflation Narrative Still Rests With the Pandemic

At several points during the Q&A portion of the conference call, Powell offered his version of inflation’s recent history, its origins and drivers. I was surprised to hear him claim that the economy is still dealing with pandemic-related disruptions that are propping up inflation. Perhaps this was a thinly veiled attempt to excuse this year’s under-appreciation of inflation’s stickiness. Powell also blamed technical factors for inflation’s stickiness: the way housing rents are calculated, lags in the data, and “temporary factors like fluctuations in used car prices.” As usual, I turned a skeptical ear toward this narrative because Powell, as he consistently does, absolved the Fed of any responsibility in aiding and abetting inflation’s stickiness by keeping rates too low for too long. I reviewed the case for why the Fed should have cut earlier in “Why Monetary Policy Was Late In Responding to the Pandemic-Era Inflation Surge“). At least this year’s experience and the learning response suggests the Fed will be more circumspect. Victory over inflation is not quite at hand yet.

The Fiscal Wildcard

Circumspection and caution should be keywords going into 2025 and beyond given the uncertainties in fiscal policy. A deepening tariff war and significant tax cuts threaten the Federal Reserve’s fragile dance with inflation-fighting. The mix of opinions within the Fed are telling. In describing how individual Fed members incorporated fiscal policy risks into their forecasts, Powell responded that some members chose to try to estimate fiscal impacts, some chose to leave out fiscal impacts, and others chose not to indicate whether they included fiscal policy. That is quite a mix! Powell made it sound like people stubbornly constructed their forecasts. Anyway, this inconsistency means that the reality of fiscal actions could drive inflation estimates even higher and cause even greater caution at the Fed.

King Dollar

The U.S. dollar (DXY) was the big post-Fed winner. Fresh strength in the U.S. dollar drove the Invesco CurrencyShares Euro Currency Trust (FXE) to a new 2-year low. This breakdown sets up FXE to eventually retest the lows from 2022. Accordingly, I am finally fully on the strong dollar bandwagon. I also expect the stock market to struggle to hit new all-time highs while the U.S. dollar makes new highs.