Gold Vs Gold Stocks: Bullish Anomaly Developing?
Over the past few months, mining stocks have returned to offering excellent leverage to the advance in prices for precious metals. Yet, during the recent pullback, the downside leverage has been absent. This is atypical behavior as mining stocks usually lead the metals and generate leveraged gains (or losses). This could be a bullish development, suggesting that investors in mining stocks believe they have the seen the bottom and are unwilling to sell despite the recent dip in gold prices.
Precious metals had a powerful start to the year, with gold climbing more than $100 and silver rocketing roughly $3 higher during the first three weeks of January. But the rally has since faded with both metals giving back nearly all of their 2015 gains.
Mining stocks typically offer leverage to the movement in the gold or silver price. From the start of 2002 until the end of 2007, gold went up roughly 203%. During the same time period, the HUI index of mining stocks rocketed 547% higher. That is leverage of roughly 2.7 times. You will notice that the leverage cuts both ways, as gold dropped 41% from the high mark on 9/06/11 until the 11/06/14 low, while mining stocks (HUI) fell by 77%. The leverage to the downside was 1.8x.
Anomalies pop up such as the period from 2008 to the end of last year. During this time period mining stocks were down 60%, despite gold being up 44%. So the positive correlation and leveraged gains are not consistent, which I will discuss more later in this article.
During the latest rally from mid-December 2014 to mid-January 2015, the leveraged gains that investors grew accustomed to during the early phases of the gold bull market returned. Gold advanced by 12% from the mid-December low to the mid-January peak. During the same time period, gold stocks advanced by a massive 37%, generating leverage of 3.1 times the advance in the gold price!
The really interesting aspect of the latest advance and pullback is that gold stocks have not registered a leveraged decline this time around. From the peak on 1/20/15 to 2/26/15, gold stocks declined by the exact same amount as gold, -8%. Investors were able to capture 3.1x leverage to the upside, without being penalized by that same leverage to the downside. This has resulted in a total gain of 26% for gold stocks since the 12/2o/14 low, despite the fact that gold is only up 3%. The leverage is an astounding 8.7 times over the last two months!
The miners are not following the metals lower and this is a significant development, as mining stocks typically lead the metals (either higher or lower). This is driven partly by lower energy costs improving mining margins. But it also seems that investors are not convinced that the pullback in gold and silver will last and continue to view mining stocks as undervalued. This could indicate that we are about to see a bounce in precious metals in the near term and that edging into new positions could be warranted.
While we advocate holding physical metals in your possession first and foremost, the leverage mentioned above is why we believe that mining stocks will offer better returns going forwards.
While the leverage cuts both ways, it has not been as severe to the downside as of late. From the top in September of 2011 until the low during November of 2014, gold dropped by 44% and gold stocks (HUI) fell by 77%. The decline in gold stocks was 1.8 times as severe as the drop in the gold price.
This leverage occurs because a small change in the gold price translates into a huge change to the profit margin of a mining company. For example, if a mining company has all-in costs of $1,000 and sells the gold for $1,200, they have a profit margin of $200 per ounce. If the gold price goes up by $200 to $1,400, they now have a margin of $400. While the gold price increased by just 16%, their profit margin doubled (+100%).
However, mining stocks don’t always offer such leverage. During periods when costs are climbing rapidly, particularly energy, labor, and borrowing costs, the leverage declines. When investors lose their risk tolerance or trust in the markets, they will favor metals over mining stocks. This occurred around the time of the 2008 financial crisis and ensuring years, when investors favored the metals over the miners.
So then, how can we determine if we entering a period when mining stocks are going to outperform gold? When will mining stocks generate positive leverage to the advance in the gold price?
The HUI/Gold ratio can lend insight. When the ratio is below the gold line, I expect gold stocks to outperform the metals (to the upside or downside). When the ratio is above the gold line, I expect gold stocks to underperform the metal and gold to outperform. At the current ratio of 0.16, gold stocks are near the most undervalued they have been since the start of the bull market back in 2001. There has been a nice bounce in the past few months, but the ratio still needs to double to reach equilibrium. The bottom line is that mining stocks remain oversold and undervalued relative to the metals that they produce and this suggests leveraged gains in the near future.
Of course, not all mining companies are created equally and we always aim to outperform the HUI. When analyzing which mining stocks to buy, we look for companies that have high grade mines with low costs, a high growth profile, experienced management, low political risk, mining-friendly governments/tax incentives, blue-sky pipeline projects, the ability to secure financing at favorable terms, high insider ownership and projects that are attractive takeover targets for the majors.
The HUI/Gold ratio is is one of the many tools that we use to determine the investment strategies outlined in the Gold Stock Bull Contrarian Report (50% ...
more
"Some of the top mining stocks to look into: GG, ABX, YAM, NEM. A better business model and usually better returns can be had from streamers or royalty stocks such as SLW, FNV, RGLD. They make an upfront payment for a % of future production or revenue. Diversified exposure is possible via an ETF like GDX or GDXJ."
Thanks for this!
Really nice post, thanks.
The comment was deleted!
Hey guy, does it kill you to be polite? Maybe you don't like the way she said it, but while I don't mind having to go to your site to get the info, I don't like finding out I can't get it either. You might want to remember that some of us are just starting to look into gold and need some pointers before we can do our own research. Some examples of what you characterize as 'mining stocks' is all I'd ask for.
Thanks for the recommendations Jason. Apologies for the "guy," I didn't mean anything by it. I've added you to my follow list.
Well, I find it rude that after I spent hours on research and analysis and provided the info for free, a reader complains about possibly having to read a few lines of promotional material on my site. It is par for the course to see an ad or promotional material on a site providing desired information for free. But to request that I send her stock picks because she "doesn't like having to go to your site (and probably subjecting myself to a sales pitch)" is a little rich. And no Kate, taking a second to follow or click on a share button is not a fair exchange of value for all of the time it takes to identify the best in breed mining stocks amongst a field of hundreds of companies.
But since you weren't rude Wendell, other than calling me 'guy', here are some of the top mining stocks to look into: GG, ABX, YAM, NEM. A better business model and usually better returns can be had from streamers or royalty stocks such as SLW, FNV, RGLD. They make an upfront payment for a % of future production or revenue. Diversified exposure is possible via an ETF like GDX or GDXJ.
Best of luck!
What are some of the miners you suggest? I don't like having to go to your site (and probably subjecting myself to a sales pitch) to see the details.