Would The Fed Hike Interest Rates In A Month Where The CPI Is Negative?

Crashing energy prices could drive headline inflation below zero, creating a rare backdrop for policymakers.

We may find out in December.

The Fed meets on December 9, 2026.

It is a near certainty the Fed hikes interest rates. Call it 99+ percent.

Despite a lot of chatter about a 50 basis point hike, that’s not going to happen no matter how bad the PCE report is on November 26.

Question of the Day

Negative CPI Reading Quite Possible

Energy prices will decline.

And if there is very tame Owners’ Equivalent Rent (OER) it can easily happen.

Shelter is over 35 percent of the CPI with OER nearly 26 percent. Energy was 7.65 percent of the CPI in October.

If shelter comes in flat, and energy is down big, we are going to see a negative CPI reading the day after the Fed hikes.

Energy Q&A With Grok

Mish: What is the projection for the energy component of the CPI report for November?

Grok: Projections for the energy component of the November 2026 CPI (due for release December 10, 2026) point to a significant decline, on the order of roughly −2.5% month-over-month. globalmacrolens.com

The most detailed publicly available nowcast comes from GlobalMacroLens (updated as of November 19, 2026). It estimates the energy component at −2.53% m/m (weight ~7.2%), contributing about −0.184 percentage points to headline CPI.

This is derived from weekly EIA fuel prices (among other free public data) to bridge the energy leaves of the CPI basket. The same nowcast puts headline CPI at about +0.04% m/m (3.9% y/y) and core at +0.25% m/m (2.9% y/y). globalmacrolens.com

Prediction markets (e.g., Kalshi) price headline around −0.1% m/m / 3.7% y/y.

GlobalMacroLens Baseline

What Would It Take to Go Negative?

You only need roughly another −0.05 pp of contribution to reach something like −0.01% (or a bit more for a clearer negative print).

  • Energy alone: An extra ~0.7 percentage-point decline (i.e., energy around −3.2% to −3.5% m/m instead of −2.5%) would do it, all else equal. That is plausible if the late-month gasoline drop is a bit steeper than the weekly EIA data already embedded in the nowcast.

  • Shelter help: Because of its high weight, a 0.1 pp slower shelter reading (e.g., +0.15–0.20% instead of the recent ~0.3% pace) adds roughly another −0.035 pp of drag.

  • Combination (the most realistic path): Energy at roughly −3.0% m/m + shelter closer to +0.15–0.20% (or even just a bit softer than the +0.29% core-services assumption) easily clears the zero line. Food or core-goods softness would help further but is not required.

Grok Comment: This lines up with market pricing (Kalshi median around −0.1% m/m) and commentary noting that the sharp gasoline/oil drop is the main swing factor for a soft headline print. Shelter is slower-moving and less likely to surprise dramatically to the downside in a single month, so the energy outcome is the bigger variable.

Genuine Tossup

I give a lot of credence to the betting markets.

So, I am upping my 35 percent chance off the top of my head answer to Michael Lebowitz.

I now think a Fed hike in a month with a negative CPI reading is a genuine tossup, if not slightly odds on.

Note that the BLS rounds to a single digit. Thus -0.049 would get rounded to 0.0.

I calculate to two digits. If the judge is a two digit calculation, I think the odds are 60 percent that the discussed event occurs. Otherwise, flip a coin.

Related Posts

November 7, 2026: Making Healthcare Harder to Get Won’t Make Healthcare More Affordable

Here’s a well thought out Tweet on Healthcare.

November 10, 2026: CPI Hotter than Expected Again. Expect a December Fed Rate Hike

This was the third consecutive bad month for CPI inflation.

November 18, 2026: Only One Republican Senator Opposes Wasting $450 Billion More in Iran

Rand Paul blasts Republican warmongering priorities in the lame duck Session.

“The American public is going to see this as financing the Iran war. It will lead to more inflation”

“At this point, the entire fiscal conservative movement in the Senate is only me.”

Comments