Rising Oil Prices Are Wreaking Havoc Across The Market

The S&P 500 (SPY) finished the day lower by approximately 40 bps, despite starting up nearly 80 bps. The index was driven higher early by a sharp volatility reset, with the VIX 1-day falling from a close of 34 to around 16 at the open. Once that volatility crush faded, equities had little support and drifted lower.

It’s not that volatility isn’t low enough to push the market higher; it’s that there is very little positive vanna left. Most positioning above spot is negative vanna, so there’s no meaningful re-hedging flow to support further upside. Once oil prices began rising, selling followed.

WTI rose above $102, triggering a breakout toward $105. Based on resistance levels dating back to 2022, oil could continue higher, potentially toward $112.

Ultimately, oil remains in the driver’s seat, and it continues to weigh on equities. More importantly, it is tightening financial conditions across the broader market complex—a process that is likely to persist as long as oil continues to rise.

What’s more interesting is the divergence beginning to emerge in inflation signals. Five-year, five-year forward breakeven inflation expectations are falling, while 5-year CPI swaps are rising. Typically, these measures move together, but that relationship has broken down. The 5-year CPI swap is moving higher, the 5y5y breakeven is falling, and the 10-year CPI is drifting modestly higher.

I generally avoid relying heavily on breakevens because they can be noisy. Taken at face value, the move might suggest rising disinflation expectations—but that interpretation is likely misleading.

The decline in the 5y5y forward appears to be driven less by falling inflation expectations and more by rising real yields. In particular, the 10-year real yield is rising faster than the 5-year real yield, implying the market is pricing tighter financial conditions and higher real rates further out the curve.

We saw a similar dynamic in 2022, when 5y5y breakevens fell sharply as real yields surged. That episode suggests breakevens can give a false signal, appearing to point to disinflation when the real driver is tightening via higher real rates.

When you factor in the recent surge in oil, the picture becomes clearer. Inflation pressure is building at the front end, but rising real yields are offsetting that impulse in breakevens. This divergence is likely a function of real rate dynamics, liquidity conditions in the TIPS market, and a lag in repricing.

More importantly, it reinforces the broader message: financial conditions are tightening.