It's Getting Harder To Influence The Fed

The Economist has an interesting article discussing central bank independence:

Mr Trump has already appointed a majority of the sitting governors of the Federal Reserve Board. Had he kept his mouth shut but appointed more doveish types, he might have achieved the same end without the outcry.

That sounds reasonable at first glance, but there are some tricky issues here that need to be disentangled. First of all, what is “the same end” that President Trump achieved? Conventional wisdom says that he failed to get Jerome Powell to adopt a low-interest rate policy. Yet the article refers to a dovish policy, which might or might not be the same thing.

Also note that while Trump replaced Janet Yellen with a slightly more hawkish person, Fed policy has actually become more dovish under Powell’s leadership, as NGDP growth has accelerated sharply since 2016. (Inflation has increased more modestly.) Recall that Ben Bernanke suggested that interest rates were not the way to judge the stance of monetary policy; rather we should look to NGDP growth and inflation.  He’s right.

The ironies keep piling up. Trump says he’s a “low-interest rate guy”, and everyone seems to assume that he favors easy money. On any given day those two objectives line up. But over the months and years, they move in opposite directions. Easier money leads to faster inflation and NGDP growth, and higher interest rates. So what does Trump “truly favor”?  Hard to say.  It’s not clear that he’s even thought about this distinction. Indeed even well-informed people often gloss over this issue.

And it gets even more complicated when you consider the Fed’s inflation target. What does it mean to talk about hawks and doves in an institution that is committed to a 2% inflation target? Is it likely that a “dove” like Janet Yellen would have pushed inflation up to 3%, or higher? That sort of outcome was plausible when President Nixon was pressuring Arthur Burns back in the early 1970s, but today it seems highly implausible.

1 2
View single page >> |
How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience. Users' ratings are only visible to themselves.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.