Photo by James Baltz on Unsplash
 

As part of our ongoing series at The Acquirer’s Multiple, each week we spotlight a stock from our Stock Screeners that might be a deeply undervalued gem hiding in plain sight. This week’s spotlight is CF Industries Holdings, Inc. (CF) — one of the world’s largest nitrogen fertilizer producers, supplying ammonia, urea, UAN, and other nitrogen products essential to global agriculture and industrial markets.
 

Business Overview

CF Industries operates a portfolio of world-class nitrogen manufacturing complexes strategically located in the U.S. and the U.K., with strong advantages in scale, low-cost natural gas feedstock, and export access. Fertilizer demand tends to fluctuate with crop prices, planting activity, and natural gas input costs — but CF’s position as a top-tier producer enables it to generate substantial free cash flow across the cycle.

The company’s long-lived assets, disciplined capital allocation, and shareholder-friendly policy (including significant buybacks and dividends) have historically allowed CF to compound value even in volatile commodity environments.
 

What Is IV/P (Intrinsic Value to Price)?

IV/P tells you whether a stock offers more intrinsic value than the price you’re paying. The ratio blends earnings power, reinvestment efficiency, and capital-return policy to estimate a conservative measure of worth.

IV/P > 1 → Undervalued
IV/P < 1 → Overvalued

CF’s IV/P = 1.10, meaning intrinsic value is estimated to be ~10% higher than the current market price — a modest but meaningful signal of undervaluation.
 

Supporting Metrics

CF’s AM of 7 places it firmly in classic value territory. While not as extremely discounted as deep cyclicals, it reflects a market assumption of middling or declining future profitability — despite CF continuing to generate robust cash flow.
 

Revenue & Profitability

Despite the downturn from the 2022 fertilizer boom, CF is still producing double-digit margins, strong earnings, and healthy cash flow — showing resilience even as nitrogen prices normalize.
 

Balance Sheet Strength

The balance sheet is solid, with manageable leverage and ample liquidity. CF’s capital-intensive operations require ongoing reinvestment, but cash generation comfortably supports debt servicing, dividends, and buybacks.
 

Capital Returns

CF continues to aggressively return capital to shareholders, primarily through substantial buybacks, which remain a key driver of intrinsic value growth.
 

Why CF Might Be Undervalued

CF sits at the intersection of several overlooked value factors:

• Cyclical pessimism has compressed multiples despite strong normalized profitability.
• Global nitrogen demand remains steady and structurally linked to population growth and food needs.
• North American gas cost advantages give CF a durable competitive moat against higher-cost international producers.
• Share repurchases and dividends steadily return cash to investors.

With an IV/P of 1.10, an Acquirer’s Multiple of 7, and strong free cash flow, CF appears to be priced as if fertilizer margins will continue contracting indefinitely — yet even in a normalized environment, CF demonstrates the capacity to compound capital at attractive rates.
 

Conclusion

With an IV/P of 1.10, strong free cash flow, and a competitive cost structure supporting attractive margins, CF Industries (CF) offers a compelling value proposition within the agricultural commodities sector. For investors seeking exposure to essential industrial inputs with steady long-term demand and disciplined capital allocation, CF may represent a durable, cash-generating business trading at a discount to intrinsic value.

More By This Author:

Our Calculation Of Intrinsic Value: NVIDIA Corporation
This Week’s Deep-Value Stock Screen: Energy & Financials Dominate Again
Why Top Investors Are Buying Constellation Brands