Not All Markets Are Equal

“Davidson” submits:

Not all markets are equal. Advisors typically recommend that investors balance portfolios globally. Now that sufficient history is available one needs to question this routine recommendation. Market history from 2008’s ‘Great Recession’ is instructive. Intl Markets as represented by the MSCI All Capital World Index excluding the US (ACWX) have been recommended as higher growth markets (especially the EmgMkts asset class) for more than 20yrs. This recommendation is based on Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) which Harry Markowitz developed in 1952.

(Click on image to enlarge)

The back story is that Markowitz, a mathematician, created a statistical model which defined volatility as ‘risk’. His view sought to take human psychology out of the investment decision-making process using an analysis of market price trends. Over the decades MPT gained favor with pension and endowment managers as ‘the scientific approach’ and has evolved into the emergence of Hedge Funds and the Financial Planning industry that is now ubiquitously applied by computers to hundreds of millions of retirement plans. Today much of short-term market pricing is driven by algorithms coupled to past price trends which are believed by their designers to forecast future trends. Many have come to believe that computer guidance eliminates the variables of human psychology. The facts are that algorithms designed by humans carry all the biases of human perception. Because the output is computer-driven, many have come to believe it is bias-free. Sadly it is not and MPT ignores key fundamentals.

The heavy reliance on MPT driven allocations and periodic rebalancing between specified asset classes ignores the fact that market performances are unequal. When the ACWX is compared to the SP500, the SP500 out-performance is unmistakable. Investors should question “Why is this so?”

The SP500 out-performs all Intl markets longer-term. The answer is more complex than a simple note can do justice. But, the essence of the explanation is that the US is the only Free Market globally. The US marketplace is fundamentally different. Everywhere else markets are riddled with government social engineering policies that restrict the freedom of investors to allocate capital to the opportunities with the highest expected returns. Even with a history of US  political schemes to drive economic activity to achieve political/social outcomes, the US has always found the Free Market lane.

1 2
View single page >> |

Disclosure: The information in this blog post represents my own opinions and does not contain a recommendation for any particular security or investment. I or my affiliates may hold positions or ...

How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience.


Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.