Gold Producers in a Shifting Macro Landscape

Gold’s break above USD 3,000 per ounce in Q1 2025—a roughly 40% increase since year-end 2023—is a reflection of the revived interest in mining companies amid economic uncertainty and geopolitical risks.¹ The S&P Commodity Producers Gold Index has responded with a 64% total return over the past 12 months,² outpacing the spot price of gold (44%) and silver (23%) bullion and confirming mining companies’ relatively higher sensitivity to metal prices. However, the lift has been uneven with high beta mid caps seeing the highest returns, while large caps delivered only modest gains.

Composition and Methodology Overview for the S&P Commodity Producers Gold Index

The S&P Commodity Producers Gold Index serves as a snapshot of the listed gold universe, and as of June 18, 2025, drew 59 of the largest, most liquid producers and royalty firms from the S&P Global BMI. To be included, constituents must trade on developed market exchanges, have a float-adjusted market capitalization of at least USD 500 million (USD 250 million for current constituents) and a minimum three-month ADVT of USD 1 million (USD 500,000 for current constituents). The index is float-market-cap weighted with a single company cap of 10% and rebalanced every June and December.

(Click on image to enlarge)

Gold Producers Delivered Two Times Bullion’s Return at Twice the Volatility

After a challenging 2021-2022 period, gold equities rebounded significantly. The S&P Commodity Producers Gold Index was up 53% YTD,³ nearly doubling gold’s rise of 28%. Similarly, volatility has remained roughly double. A 10-15% pullback in early April—sparked by new U.S. tariffs, higher real yields, profit-taking and jurisdictional uncertainties—demonstrated gold producer equities’ tendency to overshoot before recovering.

(Click on image to enlarge)

Small Caps Drove Return Dispersion as Large Caps Lagged

A closer look reveals significant return dispersion across index constituents. Over the past 12 months,⁴ the top-performing quintile of stocks (typically smaller operators) has more than doubled, while the bottom quintile, dominated by mega caps and royalty names, achieved only modest gains. Additionally, currency fluctuations and macro policy further contributed to the divergence. Producers with operational costs in ZAR or AUD enjoyed an added margin tailwind. Conversely, large, diversified miners could not match the positive momentum of mid-cap companies.⁵

Conclusion

Gold equities remained a leveraged, but often volatile, proxy for bullion, recently gaining roughly twice as much in upswings and experiencing outsized losses during downturns. Also, the sector has seen low-cost mining companies being rewarded, FX advantages and disciplined capital allocation, with little regard for size. With free cash flow surging, dividends and buybacks have been increasing, and consolidation among mega caps is expected to continue.^{6, 7} The S&P Commodity Producers Gold Index is a key measurement of the gold equity story and which trends are truly beyond the bullion in driving performance.

¹ Why Has the Price of Gold Risen So Sharply?

² As of June 18, 2025

³ As of June 18, 2025

⁴ Ending June 18, 2025

⁵ Gold Investors, It's Time To Let Go Of Gold Miners

⁶ Mining M&A in 2024 – Gold dominates M&A space for 2nd consecutive year

⁷ BlackRock World MiningTrust plc

More By This Author:

Quarterly Changes May Not Be Constant
Tech Titans and Global Champions: A Look Inside the S&P Global 100
The Importance Of Defense: En Garde!