Receiving a request for a CPA Letter is common for some self-employed borrowers during the mortgage process. But what happens if you submit your letter and the mortgage lender says it cannot be accepted?
A rejected or questioned CPA Letter does not necessarily mean your mortgage application will be denied. In many cases, the lender may simply need additional information, clarification, corrections, or a different form of documentation.
The important thing is to understand why the CPA Letter was not accepted and respond to the lender's request accurately and promptly.
What Is a CPA Letter for a Mortgage?
A CPA Letter for Mortgage is a professional document prepared by a Certified Public Accountant to address specific information requested by a mortgage lender.
For self-employed borrowers, a lender may request information related to business ownership, self-employment, business activity, or another financial matter.
The exact requirements vary by lender and loan program. There is no single universal CPA Letter format that will satisfy every mortgage lender.
A CPA Letter is also generally a supporting document. It does not automatically replace tax returns, tax transcripts, financial statements, bank statements, or other documents required during underwriting.
Why Might a CPA Letter Be Rejected?
There are several reasons a lender may reject, question, or request changes to a CPA Letter.
1. The Letter Does Not Address the Lender's Request
One of the most common problems is that the letter does not provide the specific information requested by the lender.
For example, the lender may ask for confirmation of a particular business fact, but the CPA Letter may provide only general information about the borrower's accounting relationship.
Solution
Ask the lender to identify exactly what information is missing.
Then provide the written request to your CPA and ask whether the letter can be updated to address the specific requirement.
2. The Letter Uses a Generic Template
A generic CPA Letter found online may not satisfy a particular lender's requirements.
Different lenders may have different policies regarding format, wording, information, and supporting documentation.
Solution
Always ask your mortgage lender whether it has a preferred template or specific requirements before requesting a CPA Letter.
If the lender provides a form, give that form directly to your CPA.
3. Missing Information
A lender may reject or return a CPA Letter because required information is missing.
Depending on the request, the lender may expect information concerning:
Borrower's name
Business name
Business structure
Self-employment information
Ownership information
CPA-client relationship
Specific facts requested by the lender
CPA contact information
Solution
Ask the lender for a complete list of missing information and provide it to your CPA.
Do not guess what the lender wants. Get the requirement directly from the underwriting team or loan officer.
4. Information Does Not Match Other Documents
Inconsistencies can raise questions during mortgage underwriting.
For example, the business name, ownership percentage, dates, or other information in the CPA Letter may differ from the information shown on tax returns or business documents.
Solution
Review the CPA Letter against your other mortgage documents before submission.
If you identify an inconsistency, contact your CPA and lender to determine which information is correct and what documentation is needed to resolve the issue.
5. Unsupported Statements
A CPA should only provide information that can appropriately be supported through professional records or knowledge of the client.
A lender may question a CPA Letter if it contains statements that are too broad, unsupported, or outside the appropriate scope of the CPA's professional knowledge.
Solution
Ask your CPA what information can appropriately be confirmed based on the records available.
A professional CPA Letter should be factual and accurate rather than written simply to satisfy a desired outcome.
6. The Lender Requires Additional Documentation
Sometimes the CPA Letter itself is acceptable, but the lender still needs additional documents.
This can happen because a CPA Letter is not intended to replace the lender's complete underwriting documentation.
For example, a lender may still request:
Tax returns
IRS tax transcripts
Bank statements
Profit and loss statements
Business tax returns
Other financial records
Fannie Mae's current guidance includes specific requirements for documenting and analyzing self-employed income, including applicable tax documentation and other records.
Solution
Follow the lender's complete documentation checklist rather than assuming the CPA Letter satisfies every requirement.
7. The CPA-Client Relationship Is Unclear
A lender may want to understand the professional relationship between the CPA and the borrower.
If the letter does not clearly identify the relationship when such information is required, the lender may request clarification.
Solution
Ask the lender what type of relationship information it needs and provide those instructions to the CPA.
The CPA should accurately describe the professional relationship based on the actual engagement.
8. The CPA's Contact Information Is Missing
A lender may need to verify the document with the accounting professional.
If the CPA Letter does not contain appropriate contact information, the lender may request a revised version.
Solution
Make sure the letter contains appropriate professional contact information when required by the lender.
9. The Letter Is Outdated
A lender may question a CPA Letter if the information is too old for its current underwriting requirements.
The acceptable age of documentation can vary.
Solution
Ask the lender whether it requires an updated CPA Letter and, if so, what date or information period it needs.
Do not automatically reuse an old letter from a previous mortgage application.
10. The Lender Has Changed Its Documentation Requirements
Mortgage underwriting requirements can change, and requirements may differ between lenders.
A CPA Letter that was accepted for a previous mortgage application may not meet the requirements for a new application.
Solution
Always obtain current requirements directly from your lender.
Do not assume that a letter accepted by another lender will automatically be accepted by your current lender.
Does a Rejected CPA Letter Mean Your Mortgage Is Denied?
Not necessarily.
A lender questioning or rejecting a CPA Letter does not automatically mean that the mortgage application has been denied.
The lender may simply be requesting:
A corrected letter
Additional information
Supporting documents
Updated documentation
A lender-specific form
Clarification about the borrower's business
The best response is to ask your loan officer or underwriting team exactly what is needed to resolve the issue.
What Should You Do If Your CPA Letter Is Rejected?
If your CPA Letter is rejected, avoid immediately requesting a completely new letter without understanding the reason.
Instead, follow these steps.
Step 1: Ask Why It Was Rejected
Request a clear explanation from your lender.
Ask whether the problem is related to missing information, wording, documentation, dates, or another issue.
Step 2: Get the Request in Writing
If possible, obtain the lender's requirements in writing.
This gives your CPA a clear reference when preparing a revised document.
Step 3: Contact Your CPA
Provide your CPA with the lender's comments and documentation requirements.
Step 4: Provide Additional Records
If the CPA needs additional information to verify a fact, provide the requested records promptly.
Step 5: Review the Revised Letter
Before submitting the revised CPA Letter, check the information carefully.
Step 6: Submit It Through the Correct Channel
Follow your lender's instructions for submitting the revised document.
How to Prevent CPA Letter Problems
The easiest way to deal with a rejected CPA Letter is to reduce the possibility of rejection in the first place.
Get Lender Instructions First
Do not start with a generic template. Start with the lender's request.
Use Accurate Information
Names, business details, dates, and ownership information should be accurate and consistent.
Provide Complete Documentation
Give your CPA the relevant information needed to prepare the requested letter.
Communicate Your Deadline
If your mortgage transaction has a deadline, tell your CPA in advance.
Review Before Submission
Carefully review the completed CPA Letter before giving it to your lender.
CPA Letter and Mortgage Underwriting
A CPA Letter is only one part of the mortgage underwriting process.
For self-employed borrowers, lenders may need to evaluate the stability and continuity of income and the financial strength of the business.
Fannie Mae's current guidance states that lenders should consider factors such as the borrower's history of self-employment, the nature of the business, and the financial strength of the business when evaluating self-employed income.
This means a CPA Letter may provide useful supporting information, but it does not determine whether the borrower qualifies for a mortgage.
CPA Letter vs. Mortgage Approval
It is important to separate the CPA's role from the lender's role.
The CPA
The CPA provides professional information that can appropriately be supported based on the CPA's records and relationship with the client.
The Mortgage Lender
The lender evaluates the complete application and determines whether the borrower meets its applicable underwriting requirements.
A CPA Letter does not guarantee:
Mortgage approval
Loan qualification
A specific loan amount
A specific interest rate
Closing approval
What If the Lender Wants Different Wording?
If your lender says the wording is not acceptable, do not rewrite the CPA Letter yourself.
Instead, ask the lender for its preferred language or template and provide it to your CPA.
The CPA can then determine whether the requested wording accurately represents information that can appropriately be confirmed.
Why Professional Accuracy Matters
A CPA Letter is a professional document.
It should accurately reflect the information available to the CPA and should not contain statements that cannot be appropriately supported.
Trying to make a letter say something that is not supported can create additional problems during the mortgage process.
Accuracy is more important than simply making the document fit a particular desired outcome.
How Concepts CPA Can Help
At Concepts CPA, we provide professional accounting, bookkeeping, taxation, and CPA Letter services for clients throughout the United States.
We understand that mortgage documentation can be time-sensitive and that self-employed borrowers may face additional documentation requests.
If your lender has requested a CPA Letter, our team can help you understand the request and prepare appropriate professional documentation based on the lender's requirements and information available to us.
Our focus is on professionalism, accuracy, and clear communication.
Final Thoughts
A rejected CPA Letter does not necessarily mean your mortgage application has failed.
In many situations, the lender may simply need additional information, corrections, updated documentation, or a letter that addresses its specific requirements.
The most important step is to find out exactly why the letter was not accepted. Once you understand the lender's request, provide that information to your CPA and work through the required corrections.
Avoid using generic templates, making unsupported statements, or submitting inconsistent information.
If your mortgage lender requests a CPA Letter, careful preparation and clear communication can help you respond to the documentation request more efficiently.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why would a mortgage lender reject a CPA Letter?
A lender may reject or question a CPA Letter because it is missing required information, uses an inappropriate format, contains inconsistent information, includes unsupported statements, or does not address the lender's specific request.
Does a rejected CPA Letter mean my mortgage is denied?
No. A rejected or questioned CPA Letter does not automatically mean your mortgage application has been denied. The lender may simply need corrections or additional documentation.
Can I use the same CPA Letter for another lender?
You should check with the new lender first. Different lenders may have different requirements, and an older letter may not satisfy the new lender.
Can I change the CPA Letter myself?
It is better not to alter a professional CPA Letter yourself. If changes are required, obtain the lender's instructions and provide them to your CPA.
What should I do if the lender wants different wording?
Ask the lender for its exact wording or template and provide it to your CPA. The CPA can determine what can appropriately be included.
Can a CPA Letter guarantee mortgage approval?
No. A CPA Letter is supporting documentation and does not guarantee mortgage approval.
How can I avoid CPA Letter delays?
Obtain the lender's requirements first, provide complete information to your CPA, communicate your deadline, and review the completed letter for accuracy before submission.
Comments
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.