Wall Street Discovers AI Stocks Can Go Down: The $1 Trillion Reality Check

Wall Street’s AI rally hit a $1.3 trillion reality check as investors demand profit from massive spending.

Unsplash

Wall Street has apparently discovered something extraordinary. Artificial intelligence stocks can go down.

The Wall Street AI stock selloff has investors asking an uncomfortable question. Where are the profits?

On November 17, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell roughly 1.6%, the S&P 500 lost about 1%, and the Nasdaq Composite declined approximately 0.7%.

The selling reflected renewed concerns about technology valuations, economic uncertainty and the enormous amounts of money companies are pouring into artificial intelligence.

Reports put the broad U.S. market’s intraday loss at approximately $1.3 trillion at the session’s lowest point. This was a market-wide estimate, rather than a confirmed loss confined to AI stocks.

Apparently, spending billions on data centers is easy. Convincing shareholders those investments will produce acceptable returns is another matter.

Wall Street’s AI Love Affair Meets Basic Mathematics

For the past several years, artificial intelligence has been Wall Street’s favorite investment story.

Mention AI during an earnings call, announce another data center, or promise some miraculous productivity improvement, and investors were often willing to pay a premium.

The enthusiasm had a foundation. AI demand has driven significant growth in semiconductors, cloud computing, networking equipment and electrical infrastructure.

But somewhere along the way, investors began confusing an important technology with an investment that could never become overpriced. Those are two entirely different things.

A company can dominate an industry, generate billions in revenue and still represent a terrible investment if shareholders pay too much for its future earnings.

That principle existed long before anyone started asking chatbots to write their emails. Now investors are rediscovering it.

Nvidia: Great Company, Impossible Expectations?

Nvidia (NVDA) sits at the center of the AI investment boom. Its graphics processors have become essential equipment for companies building advanced artificial intelligence systems.

The company has benefited from extraordinary demand, strong revenue growth and substantial spending by major technology customers. None of those achievements automatically makes its stock inexpensive.

When a company becomes one of the largest holdings in major stock indexes, expectations become enormous. Investors begin demanding more than impressive results.

They want exceptional earnings, accelerating growth, expanding margins and optimistic guidance. Preferably forever.

Even excellent financial results can disappoint when the stock price already assumes near-perfect execution.

The November market volatility illustrates why investors are becoming more sensitive to valuations. Nvidia remains a major beneficiary of AI infrastructure spending. The question is how much future growth investors have already paid for.

Big Tech Keeps Spending. Investors Would Like a Receipt.

Microsoft (MSFT), Alphabet (GOOGL), Amazon (AMZN) and Meta have committed enormous resources to expanding AI computing capacity. Their investments include data centers, specialized chips, networking infrastructure and electricity requirements.

The strategy makes sense from a competitive perspective. Nobody wants to become the technology company that underestimated the next major computing platform.

Unfortunately, shareholders have a slightly different concern. They would like to know when the spending produces enough incremental revenue and profit to justify the capital committed.

An AI investment can increase revenue while still delivering disappointing returns on invested capital.

If a company spends $100 billion developing infrastructure, investors should examine the operating income generated by those assets, depreciation expenses and the cost of financing the investment. Revenue growth alone does not answer those questions.

Wall Street spent years celebrating capital expenditures as evidence of future opportunity. Now some investors are beginning to treat those same expenditures as investment commitments with future depreciation and operating costs.

A fascinating development in financial analysis.

The Real Winners Might Be Selling Electricity and Cooling

There is another side to the AI investment story. While technology companies compete to develop increasingly powerful models, somebody must supply the infrastructure keeping those systems operational.

Data centers consume substantial electricity. They require sophisticated cooling equipment, reliable power distribution, backup systems and networking connections.

Those requirements create potential opportunities for companies operating outside the most fashionable corners of Silicon Valley.

Vertiv supplies critical digital infrastructure, including thermal management and power systems. Eaton (ETN) manufactures electrical equipment used across commercial and industrial markets. GE Vernova (GEV) participates in electricity generation and grid modernization.

These companies could benefit from sustained demand for physical AI infrastructure. Of course, investors have already noticed many of them.

A company benefiting from an attractive industry trend can still become overpriced. The sensible approach involves examining earnings growth, order backlogs, margins, cash flow and valuation.

Less exciting than announcing that every stock connected to electricity will double. Considerably more useful.

The Federal Reserve Has Another Problem

The AI investment boom also creates questions for monetary policymakers. Massive infrastructure spending can support economic activity, employment and demand for equipment.

It can also increase competition for electricity, construction labor, specialized components and capital. If demand exceeds available supply, costs can rise.

Meanwhile, investors must consider whether elevated stock valuations create additional financial vulnerabilities. A sharp correction in heavily owned technology companies can affect household wealth, institutional portfolios and broader market confidence.

An AI stock selloff does not automatically create a recession. But the Federal Reserve must evaluate the relationship between investment spending, financial conditions and economic growth.

Apparently, interest rates are not complicated enough already.

Is This Another Dot-Com Bubble?

Comparisons with the late 1990s are inevitable. During the dot-com boom, investors correctly recognized that the internet would transform business.

They were considerably less successful at determining which companies deserved their valuations. Many businesses disappeared. The internet continued growing.

Artificial intelligence could follow a similar pattern in one important respect. The technology can become economically transformative while individual investments deliver disappointing returns.

There are also major differences. Today’s leading AI companies generally possess established businesses, substantial revenue and significant financial resources.

That makes a direct comparison with speculative internet startups misleading. Still, profitable companies are not immune to valuation corrections.

The lesson from previous investment booms is straightforward. Being right about a technology does not guarantee being right about the price of a stock.

Wall Street AI Stock Selloff: What Investors Should Watch Next

The November 17 selloff does not establish that the AI boom has ended. Markets experience corrections for many reasons, including interest rates, profit-taking, economic uncertainty and changing expectations.

First, watch whether AI-related revenue growth continues supporting corporate spending plans.

Second, examine free cash flow and returns on invested capital rather than relying exclusively on revenue forecasts.

Third, monitor demand for electricity, cooling, networking and other infrastructure.

Finally, compare stock valuations with realistic earnings expectations.

The companies producing the strongest long-term returns will not necessarily be those generating the loudest headlines. They will be the businesses converting demand into sustainable profits.

Wall Street spent years asking how much money companies could spend on artificial intelligence. Now investors are beginning to ask how much money they can make from it.

An excellent question. It would have been even better to ask before writing the checks.

Sources: Associated Press, Reuters, CoinGape. Company descriptions refer to their publicly disclosed businesses. Federal Reserve discussion represents MktProFin analysis.

STOCKS IN THIS ARTICLE

Also Mentions:

Comments