Tobin’s Q And CAPE

Tobin’s Q and the Shiller CAPE ratio indicate historically high market valuations through early November. By comparing prices to replacement costs and cyclically adjusted earnings, these metrics help investors assess long-term risk.

Market vs. Replacement cost, and cyclically adjusted price to earnings ratio:

Figure 1: Tobin’s q (blue, left scale), Chang early Nov. estimate for q (blue +), Shiller’s Cyclically Adjusted Price Earnings ratio (red, right scale). Q4 CAPE is data through early November. NBER defined peak-to-trough recession dates shaded gray. Source: Y-Charts, Shiller, Chang/Advisor Perspectives, NBER. 

Comments