The Missing 50-Day

Traders often exacerbate drawdowns by abandoning systems and ignoring exit rules during market chop.

Source: DepositPhotos

Every rules-based trader lives through three kinds of drawdown.

In the first, their system falls out of sync with the market. Chop punishes breakouts. Trends punish mean reversion. The edge is intact, but the regime just isn’t cooperating.

In the second, the trader falls out of sync with their system. The rules say one thing about entries, exits, and stops. The trade log says another.

In the third, both happen simultaneously—and the effects compound.

Most traders I work with can spot the first. Marcus was one of them.

He joined our Collective this spring and started off well. June arrived, and the market began to chop. By the time he wrote me, he was down 22% for the year.

“Death by a thousand cuts,” he called it. Stop-out after stop-out after stop-out.

His questions were all tactical. Where should he take profits? How should he size positions? When should he sit out entirely?

His message closed with a plea: “Any guidance on what I could do from here?”

I asked for two things. First, in two or three plain sentences, how he defined his setup and trade management. Second, I asked for charts of his trades, with entries, stops, and exits clearly labeled.

His answer for defining his exits was clear: he used the 50-day moving average. He sold two to three days after a breach.

Then I opened his charts. No 50-day. Not on a single one.

When I pointed this out, he said he’d cleared the indicators for a cleaner look. So I added it back myself.

CAI, one of his marked trades, had never dropped below its 50-day. He had sold it anyway.

He had stated one exit rule and traded another.

What was actually driving his exits surfaced slowly. In one case, a currency trade had run into profit before round-tripping to breakeven, so he’d created a new rule: sell when open profit retraced to a set fraction of its peak. That rule took him out of CAI before it moved into new highs. In other cases, he exited once a loss became too painful to hold.

Then came the line that explained why refining tactics was futile: “I’m trying to make back the losses quickly for peace of mind.”

Here is what I saw, and reflected back to him:

The choppy environment was real. He had no control over that. But foremost, he was out of sync with his system.

Chop produced cuts. Cuts produced urgency. Urgency produced disconnection. Disconnection produced more cuts.

I couldn’t tell Marcus if his system was broken. Neither could he. His trade log couldn’t tell us either, because the trades in it weren’t his system’s trades.

So I told him what I’d tell anyone in that situation: stop trading live.

Define the setup and the management in writing. Forward test only those rules in a trade log until he can follow them verbatim in a no-stakes environment. Then return with small size, where the psychological work begins.

He took it well. “I’ve been going at this solo the whole time,” he wrote. “Having someone else’s pov really helped put things into perspective.”

Sometimes, when we close this kind of gap, the system turns out to be sound. Other times we find tactics worth improving. But no improvement in tactics survives a trader who isn’t following them.

Disclaimer:

All statements are solely opinions and are for educational purposes only.

Comments