One of the most critical decisions that any property owner makes is to select the correct roofing material. Although appearance and durability are common concerns, it's important to consider the economic effects of the roofing system. The two most common choices, metal roof systems and asphalt shingles, have different benefits and expenses, which can impact the overall value of a property.
If you understand the basic differences of these types of roofing systems, you can make a smart investment.
1. Initial Installation Cost
First cost is one of the most obvious differences between metal roofs and asphalt shingles roofs. The cost of asphalt shingles is typically less and they are easier to install. This is because they're an appealing choice for homes that are on a tight budget.
Metal roofing, however, will also require a larger upfront investment because of the price of materials and the technical expertise required to install it. But all the initial costs might not be the only ones to consider when evaluating the cost.
2. Lifespan and Replacement Frequency
The lifespan of asphalt shingles varies from 15 to 30 years and depends on product quality and weather conditions. Often, metal roofs can last 40 to 70 years or longer.
Metal roofing is designed to last longer, which equates to less roofing replacement in the life of a building. Whilst the up front price tag may be higher, the savings on the roof replacement costs can be significant.
3. Maintenance Expenses
The TCO (total cost of ownership) is high due to maintenance costs. It is possible that the asphalt shingles will need more frequent repairs if they curl, crack, or were damaged during a storm.
Metal roofs typically need less maintenance than other roofing types as they are resistant to many of the issues associated with roofing. While there is still a need for occasional inspections, this will increase the lifetime value of the metal roof with lower repair costs.
4. Energy Efficiency
With utility prices on the rise, energy efficiency is becoming more and more significant. The reflective properties of a metal roof can help to keep the interior temperature cooler in the summer months.
Asphalt shingles will absorb heat more than other shingles, leading to greater cooling needs. As the technology advances, increased energy savings can be achieved, which can counterbalance some of the increased upfront cost of metal roofing.
5. Weather Resistance
Roofing systems are subject to different weather conditions during their lifetime. Metal roofing is extremely durable in resisting high winds, heavy snow, hail and rain. They are typically a very durable style of boat, and as a result, do not have many weather repairs.
Modern asphalt shingles provide better protection, but may be more susceptible to harsh weather conditions. Repairing frequently following storms could lead to rising ownership expenses.
6. Effect on property value
The roof is a key element of a property that brings in market appeal. A newer, long lasting roof appears to be a good value for the buyer, who is less inclined to worry about roof maintenance in the future.
The durability, energy efficiency, and styling of metal roofing can make them an attractive investment that increases the value of a property. Even when well installed, asphalt shingles can add positively in the sense of property value, but perhaps not in the same way.
7. Environmental Considerations
Sustainability is becoming an important factor in purchasing decisions. A number of metal roofing products have recycled content, and are completely recyclable at the end of their life.
This is generally due to the fact that asphalt shingles need to be replaced more often, generating more construction waste. Recycling options are improving for shingles, however, metal roofing has generally made greater contributions to the environment, and this may be of interest to homeowners and buyers who are concerned about the environment.
8. Insurance and Risk Factors
When calculating insurance rates, insurance companies take into account the type of roofing material used. Metal roofs can receive discounts in some areas due to their ability to withstand harsh weather and have a high degree of fire resistance.
While the amount of insurance savings may vary from insurance company to insurance company and by area, lower risk can mean lower ownership costs over the long-term. It is important for homeowners to get clarifications from their insurance providers on how the decisions they make regarding roofing could impact their coverage and premiums.
10. Purchasing an RA Leader's Handbook
Consider return on investment more than just the cost of the roofing system. While a lower cost roof might appear to be a good value up front, it may mean that there will be more repairs, more energy usage, and that the roof will need to be replaced sooner.
The durability, energy savings, maintenance savings and potential insurance benefits of metal roofing can often be greater long-term value. Despite their drawbacks, asphalt shingles are still a suitable and affordable option for many homeowners, particularly for those on a budget.
Making the Right Roofing Investment
And the most suitable roofing solution will be determined by the requirements of a property, the weather, its financial objectives and projected lifespan. While metal roofing may be more expensive than other roofing options, it offers substantial savings over the long haul for homeowners who are planning on living in their homes for many years.
On the other hand, asphalt shingles remain cost-effective and perform well, and these are still used for homes.
It's advisable to seek guidance from seasoned roofing experts, who can evaluate your property needs and offer customized suggestions, before reaching a conclusion. Homeowners can use trusted roofing experts like Artisanroofing.ca to compare performance characteristics, understand the life-cycle costs, and select a roofing system that meets their budget and value goals.
Conclusion
There are costs associated with the roofing project that go beyond the installation cost. True cost of ownership depends on factors including lifespan, maintenance, energy efficiency, weather resistance, insurance and resale value.
When making the decision between metal roofs and asphalt shingles, homeowners can use the information found in this list of the nine key differences to make a more informed choice. By taking the time and effort to invest in a roofing solution that is suitable, you'll save yourself money, enjoy a more comfortable home, and have more peace of mind for years.
Comments
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.