The pitch is familiar to anyone who has sat across a table from a real estate syndicator or scrolled through an investor deck. Strong yield, value-add upside, favorable exit multiple. The numbers are compelling. The risk section, typically buried near the back, is not.
Parker Webb has reviewed enough of those decks to recognize the pattern. As principal at FTW Investments and a developer with more than $100 million in assets under management, he’s watched investors chase high-yield opportunities into assets that looked attractive on a spreadsheet and turned out to be anything but.
“The deals that get you aren’t the obvious ones,” Webb said. “They’re the ones where the numbers work until they don’t, and by the time you figure out why, you’re already holding a problem.”
The hidden risks Webb worries about most aren’t the ones that appear in standard due diligence. They’re structural, social, and geographic factors that rarely show up in a proforma but can determine whether an asset performs or deteriorates over a holding period.
The Midwest Advantage — and Its Limits
Webb is a committed advocate for Midwestern markets. Kansas City, in particular, offers a combination of cap rate spread, population growth, and development capacity that coastal markets can’t match. But he’s quick to warn against treating the region as uniformly low-risk.
“People hear ‘Midwest’ and think it means safe and boring,” he said. “Some of it is. Some of it isn’t. The fundamentals vary enormously by submarket, sometimes by block.”
The risk factors Webb watches most closely include tenant mix quality, neighborhood trajectory, and what he calls “dependency concentration” — the degree to which a property’s performance depends on a single tenant, a single employer in the area, or a single infrastructure decision by a public agency.
A retail center anchored by a regional grocery chain may look stable. But if the surrounding neighborhood is losing population, if the road serving the center is scheduled for a reconfiguration, or if the anchor tenant is operating on a lease that expires in 18 months, the yield story changes quickly.
“Every deal has a narrative,” Webb said. “The question is whether the narrative is complete. Most of the time, the seller’s version leaves things out.”
The Deferred Maintenance Problem
One of the most consistent risk factors Webb has encountered in value-add real estate is deferred maintenance — physical deterioration that has been tolerated by previous ownership and priced into the acquisition discount without a realistic accounting of what remediation will actually cost.
The problem compounds in older commercial stock, which makes up a significant share of available inventory in Midwestern cities. Roof systems, HVAC infrastructure, electrical panels, and parking surfaces can all carry hidden costs that only surface during construction or after tenant occupancy.
“People buy the cap rate and forget they’re also buying everything the last owner didn’t fix,” Webb said. “The discount you think you’re getting can disappear inside the first 12 months if you haven’t done a thorough physical assessment.”
His standard practice is to require a third-party property condition report on every acquisition, regardless of asset age or prior renovation history. He also builds what he calls a “deferred maintenance reserve” into his underwriting, typically set higher than the physical assessment recommends, to account for the items that assessments miss.
Community Resistance as a Risk Factor
Beyond the physical and financial, Webb points to a risk that rarely appears in investor materials but has derailed projects he’s watched from the outside: community opposition.
In markets where displacement and affordability concerns are acute, developments that ignore local input or pursue rapid rent escalation can face organized resistance. Zoning challenges, negative press coverage, and sustained community pressure have killed or significantly delayed projects that were financially sound on paper.
“You can have the money, the permits, and the plan, and still have a problem,” Webb said. “If the neighborhood doesn’t want what you’re building, or doesn’t trust why you’re building it, that becomes a cost.”
His approach involves engaging community stakeholders early, before designs are finalized and before lease terms are set. The conversations take time and occasionally require adjustments to the original plan. But Webb argues the process consistently produces better outcomes, both for the community and for the investment.
“A project that has the neighborhood behind it is a different asset than one that doesn’t,” he said. “That’s not soft. That’s risk management.”
The Long Hold Perspective
Webb’s philosophy is shaped in part by his preference for long-duration holds. Rather than acquiring, optimizing, and selling on a compressed timeline, he tends to hold assets through multiple market cycles, which changes how he evaluates risk.
Short-term investors can tolerate more volatility because they can time their exit to favorable conditions. Long-term holders have to underwrite for environments that don’t yet exist. That means stress-testing assumptions about tenant stability, population trends, and infrastructure investment over periods of five to fifteen years.
“Most underwriting models assume the world stays more or less the same,” Webb said. “It doesn’t. I want to own assets that can handle a version of the world that looks different from today.”
For investors who share that orientation, the high-yield opportunity begins to look less attractive when examined through a longer lens. The asset that delivers a strong first-year yield but sits in a neighborhood with declining demographics, deteriorating infrastructure, and tenant mix that doesn’t serve local needs may be exactly the asset to avoid.
“The best deal isn’t always the one with the best headline number,” Webb said. “Sometimes it’s the one that’s still a good deal in year ten.”
Published Originally on — https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/parker-webb-on-the-hidden-risk-in-highyield-real-estate-why-chasing-returns-can-cost-you-the-asset/ar-AA20r7kV?disableErrorRedirect=true&infiniteContentCount=0
Comments
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.