
Gold has traditionally been regarded as a safe haven, particularly sought after during periods of economic uncertainty, geopolitical tensions or currency depreciation. It would therefore seem logical to assume that a major oil crisis capable of destabilizing the global economy would immediately drive its price higher.
The reality is more complex.
When an oil shock occurs, several economic and financial mechanisms come into play simultaneously. Some benefit gold, while others exert downward pressure on its price.
Historical episodes in 1973, 1979, 1990 and 2022 show that gold's reaction largely depends on monetary policy, changes in real interest rates and liquidity conditions.There is therefore no automatic correlation between soaring oil prices and an immediate rise in gold prices.
The real issue is not just the energy shock itself, but how central banks and financial markets respond to it.
Rising oil prices reignite inflationary pressures
An oil crisis generally begins with a disruption in global energy supplies. Military conflicts, economic sanctions and supply interruptions are all factors that can trigger a sharp increase in oil prices.
Oil remains an essential component of the global economy. Rising prices directly affect transportation, industrial production and distribution costs. Businesses face higher expenses and, whenever possible, seek to pass these costs on through higher selling prices.
Inflation may then accelerate again, even as economic activity begins to slow. This is precisely what makes oil shocks particularly difficult to manage: they can simultaneously accelerate price increases and weaken economic growth.
This combination, characteristic of a stagflationary environment, places central banks in a difficult position. Under normal circumstances, an economic slowdown could justify interest rate cuts to support economic activity. However, when inflation remains elevated, monetary easing risks fueling further price increases.
The US Federal Reserve (Fed) may therefore be forced to maintain a restrictive monetary policy for longer than anticipated. And this is where difficulties begin for gold.
Rising bond yields can weigh on gold
Unlike bonds, gold pays no interest. Its relative appeal therefore depends, among other factors, on the returns offered by other financial assets, particularly sovereign debt securities.
When an energy crisis reignites inflation expectations, investors reassess their outlook for US monetary policy. Previously anticipated rate cuts are postponed or even replaced by expectations of further rate hikes.
US Treasury yields may consequently rise. In such an environment, some investors temporarily favor US Treasury securities, which provide a regular income, over gold.
However, it is important to distinguish between nominal and real interest rates. For gold, real interest rates — yields adjusted for expected inflation — play a particularly decisive role.
If bond yields rise faster than inflation expectations, real interest rates increase, raising the opportunity cost of holding gold. Conversely, when inflation accelerates faster than nominal yields, real interest rates may decline, which tends to support gold prices.
An oil crisis can therefore have contrasting effects on gold, depending on how bond markets respond.
The dollar and liquidity pressures intensify the pressure on gold
A second mechanism can amplify gold's initial decline: a strengthening US dollar.
When a major crisis erupts, international investors often seek to reduce their exposure to risk and increase their cash reserves. The dollar then benefits from its status as the world's leading reserve and funding currency. This demand may be reinforced by the prospect of US interest rates remaining elevated for an extended period.
Since gold is primarily priced in dollars, a stronger US currency tends to make it more expensive for investors using other currencies.
However, another factor also comes into play: liquidity needs. During periods of severe financial turbulence, institutional investors may be forced to sell certain assets to cover losses, meet margin calls or replenish their cash reserves.
Gold, being highly liquid, may then be sold not because its fundamentals have deteriorated, but simply because it is one of the easiest assets to sell quickly.
This phenomenon was observed during the 2008 financial crisis and the early weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. In both cases, gold experienced a temporary correction before regaining its upward momentum.
During a liquidity crisis, investors do not necessarily sell what they want to sell, but what they can sell. This explains why gold can temporarily decline precisely when economic and financial risks are increasing.
The burden of US debt is gradually changing the dynamics
While high interest rates can weigh on gold in the short term, maintaining them for an extended period poses a major challenge for heavily indebted countries.
The United States must finance substantial budget deficits while regularly refinancing a considerable portion of its public debt. As existing bonds mature, they must be refinanced at prevailing market rates.
When interest rates are high, refinancing becomes increasingly expensive. Rising interest payments then absorb a growing share of federal revenues, reducing fiscal flexibility.
A potentially self-reinforcing cycle may emerge:
Budget deficits require new debt issuance.
High interest rates increase refinancing costs.
Interest payments contribute to widening deficits.
Borrowing requirements increase once again.
This situation becomes particularly challenging when the economy slows as a result of an energy shock. The government must then contend with weaker growth, high public spending and potentially rising borrowing costs.
The Federal Reserve also faces competing objectives: containing inflation, sustaining economic activity and maintaining financial stability.
This does not mean that it will necessarily be forced to cut interest rates rapidly. However, the longer restrictive monetary policy remains in place, the more risks to the economy and the financial system accumulate.
In the short term, high interest rates can weaken gold. Over the longer term, their consequences for debt and financial stability enhance its appeal.
A monetary policy reversal could become a powerful catalyst for gold
The real shift in market dynamics occurs when markets begin to anticipate monetary easing.
If the economic slowdown intensifies and financial pressures become excessive, the Federal Reserve may gradually change its policy stance. Investors then anticipate policy rate cuts, lower bond yields or, under certain circumstances, additional measures to support liquidity.
This shift in expectations triggers several developments favorable to gold.
First, declining real interest rates reduce the opportunity cost of holding the precious metal. Second, US monetary easing contributes to a weaker dollar, which generally supports the price of gold denominated in that currency. Finally, when investors begin to question the sustainability of fiscal trajectories and the future purchasing power of currencies, real assets regain their appeal.
Gold then benefits from a fundamental characteristic: it represents no government's debt and does not depend on the solvency of any issuer. Unlike fiat currencies, its supply cannot be increased through a monetary policy decision. It therefore serves as a store of value independent of the financial liabilities accumulated by governments.
The gold market may even begin to anticipate this reversal well before the central bank implements its first interest rate cut.
It is therefore not necessarily the rate cut itself that triggers gold's recovery, but the anticipation of a shift in the monetary policy regime.
What can we learn from previous crises?
Monetary history offers several examples of periods during which energy shocks, inflation and changes in monetary policy profoundly influenced the gold market.
The 1970s: Gold in an era of stagflation
The oil shocks of 1973 and 1979 contributed to persistent inflation across Western economies. This period was also marked by the end of the Bretton Woods system, the abandonment of the dollar's convertibility into gold and a fundamental reassessment of the international monetary order.
Gold, which traded at around $35 per ounce at the beginning of the decade, exceeded $800 at its peak in January 1980. This spectacular rise cannot be attributed solely to the oil crises. It also reflected declining confidence in currencies, periods of negative real interest rates and instability in the monetary system.
Nevertheless, this episode illustrates gold's ability to benefit from an environment characterized by high inflation and weakening monetary credibility.
2008–2011: From a liquidity crisis to monetary easing
The 2008 financial crisis provides another revealing example. At the height of the turmoil, gold experienced a significant correction, even as the global banking system faced a historic crisis. Forced liquidations and the demand for dollars temporarily weighed on its price.
However, when the Federal Reserve lowered interest rates to near zero and launched its quantitative easing programs, conditions became much more favorable to gold. The precious metal subsequently embarked on an upward trajectory that saw its price exceed $1,900 per ounce in 2011.
This episode demonstrates that an initial decline can precede a substantial rally when monetary authorities respond to a crisis with large-scale easing measures.
2022: An energy shock overshadowed by rising real interest rates
Russia's invasion of Ukraine caused energy prices to soar and intensified global inflationary pressures. Gold initially benefited from rising geopolitical risks before undergoing a correction in the following months.
The Federal Reserve embarked on a particularly rapid monetary tightening cycle, driving bond yields and the dollar sharply higher. These factors temporarily outweighed demand for inflation protection.
The events of 2022 serve as a reminder that gold responds not only to inflation and geopolitical tensions, but also to the monetary conditions they generate.
However, it would be misleading to conclude that all oil crises follow the same trajectory. Each episode depends on its economic context, initial interest rate levels, fiscal conditions and the response of central banks.
A structurally favorable environment for gold?
Beyond short-term fluctuations, several profound changes distinguish the current environment from previous cycles.
The first concerns the accumulation of public debt. The United States must now contend with historically high debt levels in nominal terms and substantial refinancing requirements. This makes both the economy and public finances particularly sensitive to a prolonged period of high interest rates.
The second structural change concerns the behavior of central banks. For several years, numerous monetary institutions have been increasing their gold reserves to diversify their assets and reduce their dependence on major reserve currencies. This demand reflects long-term strategic considerations that extend beyond interest rate expectations.
Finally, geopolitical tensions and the growing fragmentation of international trade are raising further questions about the stability of the global monetary system.
Against this backdrop, demand for gold no longer relies exclusively on Western financial investors. Institutional purchases, reserve diversification strategies and the search for assets free from counterparty risk provide structural support.
This does not, of course, guarantee a continuous rise in gold prices. Persistently high real interest rates, a particularly strong dollar or a sharp contraction in liquidity can still trigger significant corrections. However, these movements must be distinguished from long-term monetary trends.
Conclusion: A crisis can initially weaken gold before reinforcing its monetary role
An oil crisis can trigger a series of seemingly contradictory reactions in the gold market.
Initially, soaring energy prices reignite inflation expectations and may lead central banks to keep interest rates elevated. Bond yields, the dollar and liquidity pressures can then weigh on gold prices.
However, if the energy shock ultimately weakens economic growth, undermines public finances and triggers a shift in monetary policy, conditions may gradually reverse. Declining real interest rates, movements in the dollar and concerns about sovereign debt sustainability may then restore gold to a central role.
History shows that these transitions can be lengthy, uneven and accompanied by significant corrections. For long-term investors, the key is therefore to distinguish between market movements driven by immediate liquidity needs and deeper economic and monetary imbalances.
A crisis that temporarily triggers gold selling may ultimately reinforce the fundamental reasons for owning it.
Comments
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.