Intuit Holding Up Despite Fraud Issues

Our quant-based analysis for Intuit, with discussion of media reports that the company is not suffering ill effects from a brief fraud-caused suspension of filings last month. Long-term effects of the tax hack are still unclear.

Intuit's (INTU) mission is to revolutionize how people manage their financial activities. The company's objective is to greatly expand the world of electronic finance. Electronic finance encompasses three types of products and services: desktop software products that operate on customers' personal computers to automate financial tasks; products and services that are delivered via the Internet; and products and services that connect Internet-based services with desktop software to enable customers to integrate their financial activities.

The company was forced to suspend electronic filings of state tax returns via its flagship product Turbo Tax last month due to a surge in fraudulent activity. While the moratorium only lasted 24 hours, yesterday's Wall Street Journal reports that many questions remain about the incident. Both the IRS and the FBI are looking into the matter, but the company CEO Brad Smith remains confident it was not hacked or breached.

If that is true, then the implication is that hackers obtained passwords or other personal data via other data breaches or exploits of individuals and then used it the purloined data at Turbo Tax because--as by far the largest electronic filer-- most users would be using it for their taxes. It's another caution for users who like to keep a log in and password for multiple accounts.

So far, it is tough to find any real negative result for Intuit; they were already offering a promotion where state tax filing was free--which some speculated is the reason the hackers went after state tax refunds--and they have implemented a variety of changes designed to stop the fraud.

ValuEngine continues its HOLD recommendation on INTUIT INC for 2015-03-05. Based on the information we have gathered and our resulting research, we feel that INTUIT INC has the probability to ROUGHLY MATCH average market performance for the next year. The company exhibits ATTRACTIVE Sharpe Ratio but UNATTRACTIVE Book Market Ratio.

NOTE: The author uses Turbo Tax for electronic filing of taxes and has had no problems this year or any other.

ValuEngine Forecast

 

Target
Price*

Expected
Return

1-Month

97.87 -0.25%

3-Month

97.64 -0.49%

6-Month

96.32 -1.84%

1-Year

95.17 -3.00%

2-Year

115.04 17.25%

3-Year

78.81 -19.68%

Valuation & Rankings

Valuation

47.02% overvalued Valuation Rank(?)

6

1-M Forecast Return

-0.25% 1-M Forecast Return Rank

32

12-M Return

21.69% Momentum Rank(?)

83

Sharpe Ratio

1.24 Sharpe Ratio Rank(?)

98

5-Y Avg Annual Return

22.09% 5-Y Avg Annual Rtn Rank

91

Volatility

17.88% Volatility Rank(?)

86

Expected EPS Growth

-5.88% EPS Growth Rank(?)

19

Market Cap (billions)

27.15 Size Rank

96

Trailing P/E Ratio

38.48 Trailing P/E Rank(?)

36

Forward P/E Ratio

40.88 Forward P/E Ratio Rank

10

PEG Ratio

n/a PEG Ratio Rank

n/a

Price/Sales

5.93 Price/Sales Rank(?)

16

Market/Book

56.69 Market/Book Rank(?)

3

Beta

0.77 Beta Rank

64

Alpha

0.13 Alpha Rank

82

 

Disclosure:

None

STOCKS IN THIS ARTICLE

Comments