
How can a company grow its earnings year after year while its shareholders lose money? In this video, FAST Graphs co-founder Chuck Carnevale draws on Chapter 7 of All Investing Is Value Investing, which he co-authored with Professor Nathan Mauck, to explain how the price you pay can determine how much of a company’s growth shows up in your returns.
The Greater Fool Theory describes what happens when investors pay a price that’s hard to justify based on a company’s earnings because they expect someone else to pay even more. As more buyers take that bet, a stock’s price can climb well above its estimated fair value. When buyers stop paying higher prices, the stock can fall sharply or go sideways for years while earnings catch up.
Chuck uses FAST Graphs to show both outcomes. In the Accenture (ACN) example, earnings grew about 9.5% annually over the period shown, yet an investor who bought at roughly 36 times earnings would have lost about 3.5% annually. Autodesk (ADSK) illustrates how a high starting valuation can hold back returns even without a sustained price decline. During the period Chuck highlights, earnings grew about 23% annually while the stock returned less than 4% annually.
Chuck also uses Ball Corporation (BALL) to explain the three drivers of total return: earnings growth, dividends, and changes in the price-to-earnings multiple. A falling multiple can offset years of earnings growth. Buying at a more reasonable valuation can give investors a better chance of benefiting from that growth.
Watch the video to see how Chuck compares stock prices with earnings and estimated fair value on FAST Graphs. Whether you invest for growth or income, a margin of safety gives you room for error when the business or the market falls short of your expectations.

Comments
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.