The S&P Is Not A 6-Month CD

This may come as a surprise to new investors, but the S&P 500 is not a risk-free certificate of deposit (CD). For more than three years, though, it has been behaving as one. Had you purchased the S&P 500 (SPY) at the end of any week since August 2011 and held for six months, you would have ended up with a positive return 100% of the time.

cd1

 

For 179 consecutive weeks, this has been true, marking the second longest stretch in history. Only the mid-to-late 1990’s (1994-1998) had a longer streak of positive 6-month returns.

cd2

 

What does this mean for investors going forward?

This has been one of the greatest periods for buy-and-hold investors in history. As a by-product, many investors have developed unreasonable expectations for their equity holdings – that they have no risk. These investors are likely to be disappointed and with S&P 500 up only up 1% over the past six months, this disappointment may come sooner than most expect.

Historically, the odds of a positive 6-month return in equities is only 67%. Thus, in one out of every three 6-month periods an investment in the S&P 500  would have lost money. Using equities as a substitute for a savings account or  short-term certificate of deposit – money you need available in within the next year – has never been a wise idea. The recent past doesn’t change that fact even though the outcome would have been favorable in hindsight.

On a broader note, the period of nearly unrelenting advance in U.S. equities has not been lost on investors. We now live in a world where everyone wants higher beta and correlation to the S&P 500 because that is “what has worked.” This is the polar opposite sentiment to March 2009 when everyone wanted low correlation and beta to stocks.

Prudent investors today will be positioning for the future, not the recent past. For if trees don’t grow to the sky, the next few years will look markedly different. If now is not the time to prepare for that eventuality, when is?

Disclaimer: At Pension Partners, we use Bonds as our defensive position in our absolute return strategies for all of the above reasons. Bonds have provided a more ...

more
How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.
Or Sign in with