Jim Boswell Blog | Change the Dialogue on Infrastructure | TalkMarkets
Executive Director, Quanta Analytics
Contributor's Links: Globanomics
Author of Globanomics. Jim has nearly fifty years of professional experience in the development of management information and analytical business decision support systems. Broadly disciplined with exceptional experience. Education includes an MBA from the Wharton School-University of Pennsylvania, ...more

Change the Dialogue on Infrastructure

Date: Wednesday, April 7, 2021 7:14 AM EDT

I see that Senator Manchin has thrown a wrench into the "Infrastructure" discussion.  No big surprise there.  Personally, i think it offers Biden an opportunity to show how Democrats can work together and change the dialogue for the betterment of all.  And here is how.

Make the infrastructure part of a larger "Budget" issue.  It does not take a rocket science to know that by the time you can get an infrastructure bill passed we will be back closer to full employment.  That means we should be back to a somewhat more normal federal budget process.  

So here is what you do, based upon my early less than five minute search to find the Congressional Budget Office figures for the federal budget for the last fifty-years.  

First of all, recognize than we have had only 4-years (1998-2001) during the 50 where the Government ran a "surplus" budget.  In fact, we have only had another ten years where the deficit was less than 2%.  So that means only 28% of the time in the last fifty-years (during both democrat and republican administrations) have we run budgets with less than a 2% deficit.

Tell people as important as infrastructure is, you are going to do it while at the same time moving us towards a more balanced budget.  You should be able to do this with both increased taxes and strategic cuts in expenditures.  In 2015 and 2016 (Obama's last two-years), the budget deficit was -2.4% and -2.9% respectively.  During Trump's reign the federal budget worsened every year to -4.6% in 2019.

Using those last five-years (2015-2016) as a basis from which to start, knowing the economic times are going to get better, tell people you are going to submit a "real" budget the first year that includes infrastructure that reduces our levels of deficit spending to -2.0%.  

Do this without any smoke and mirrors.  Bold action like infrastructure can be teamed with bold action on the budget.  That kills two birds with one stone and would really make Biden look like he knows what he is doing.  Let the left scream bloody murder, but in the long run it will be better for everyone.  The republicans would have absolutely no place to go with this type of argument.  You get infrastructure while reducing the deficit from the Trump years.

Like i mentioned before, get Steve Ratner to pull the analysis together so you can explain what you intend to do.  Explain infrastructure as part of a larger budget question, which includes increased taxes and reduced expenditures in other non-infrastructure areas, including "defense" and "medicare" and "medicaid".  Do the medicare and medicaid by cutting costs, not services.  You are paying too much for the services.

Anyway, you get the bigger picture here.  To coin an old Nike phrase--Just Do It.

Now, here is the link to the CBO's fifty-year view of federal budget deficits and surplus.

The Federal Budget in 2019: An Infographic | Congressional Budget Office (cbo.gov)

p.s. Biden might also want to tell the people that he is going to continue to move forward along these same lines and "balance the budget" sometime in his  second term.

 

Disclaimer: This and other personal blog posts are not reviewed, monitored or endorsed by TalkMarkets. The content is solely the view of the author and TalkMarkets is not responsible for the content of this post in any way. Our curated content which is handpicked by our editorial team may be viewed here.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.