E Market Sentiment Has Improved; Q1 EPS Forecasts Still Fall

Below is a screenshot from Earnings Whisper displaying the key earnings reports to be delivered this coming week. 

Monday will find earnings reports from the likes of Citigroup (C) and Goldman Sachs (GS).  With earnings continuing to be delivered from the financial sector (XLF), investors will also receive Q1 results from outside of the sector and from the likes of Netflix, CSX Corp. (CSX), IBM (IBM) and PepsiCo (PEP). 

Bogus Claim of the Week

As we often aim to deliver the facts and remove hyperbole from the investor dialogue in favor of said facts, our latest bogus claim of the week comes directly from Clarity Financials Lance Roberts.  In his latest blog post titled “Make Stock Buybacks Illegal?, the often hyperbolic Roberts offers the following to readers/investors:

“The other problem with the share repurchases is that is has increasingly been done with the use of leverage. The ongoing suppression of interest rates by the Federal Reserve led to an explosion of debt issued by corporations. Much of the debt was not used for mergers, acquisitions or capital expenditures but for the funding of share repurchases and dividend issuance.”

Make buybacks illegal, with a question mark and highlighting the issue of buybacks with an inverted chart… that’s the Roberts way.  It aims to muddle the commentary. But make no mistake about it; the claim that increasing leverage/debt is being used to transact buybacks is a farce and stretching the relative time value of the equation, which has proven mostly consistent since the turn of the century.

As shown in the chart above from JPM, funding buybacks with debt has been stagnant since 2012 and actually rolled over in 2018.  This was a byproduct of the tax reform legislation that found corporates repatriating more cash, thus shifting the source of funding for buybacks in even greater favor of cash from debt.  But also and more importantly, buybacks have always been a vast majority cash oriented exercise by corporations and debt vs. cash generated buyback ratio almost never changes, as shown in the chart.

Investor Takeaways

Every week is seemingly a critical week for the market when the market is expressing a V-shaped recovery. With an earnings recession in the Q1 period already expected and priced into the market, guidance will prove critical to sustain the market’s rebound.  If guidance and actual Q1 results prove less than already priced in to the market, bouts of selling may find a pullback in the near future with bouts of volatility. 

This coming week also marks a VIX futures expiration week come Tuesday.  The front end of the VIX futures term structure is very steep presently, with a build-up of contango suppressing VIX-ETP prices.  With the VIX dipping below 12 last week, there is still decay and selling of the April futures contracts that needs to occur in order to exercise contracts at expiration, while converging price onto spot VIX. (See chart below)

Given the steepness of the curve and VIX futures expiration on Tuesday, the short-VOL positioning is still advantaged. Of course, based on the VIX calendar that suggests new hedges will be placed at the start of the trading week, some of the roll yield expressed in futures term structure can be mitigated and assuming this takes place on scale come Monday. 

For active portfolio managers, the present risk/reward for market bulls is characterized as leaning bearish near-term, with the probability of a market pullback increasing and coinciding with bouts of increased volatility.  While we can’t predict how earnings season will move markets, we do believe there is an above average probability that estimates have come down too far and express excessive caution on the quarter.

The market always delivers opportunity, but the opportunity can often only be realized through the preparedness of a portfolio. This begs the questions: Are you positioned to take advantage of opportunity when it is presented? Do you have cash and/or liquidity? Are you prepared to ride out potential market storms/turmoil?  

1 2 3 4 5
View single page >> |
How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience. Users' ratings are only visible to themselves.


Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.