Leading Indicators: A Look At The FSWM Stimulus Index And Rebounding Sentiment
Chris Puplava analyzes recent consumer and manufacturing data, highlighting a rise in consumer confidence and auto sales. Combined with insights from the Financial Sense Wealth Management Stimulus Index, this points to a potential manufacturing rebound through 2025, driven by lower energy costs and easing interest rates. Many of our previous guests have speculated on the possibility of an extended “Roaring 2020s” in the latter half of the decade—but will rising inflation and interest rates derail this outlook? Here’s what we’re examining.
Consumer Sentiment: A Surge in Optimism
Consumer spending, which accounts for nearly 70% of U.S. GDP, remains a critical driver of economic growth. Recent data from the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index offers encouraging news, with December's preliminary reading showing a sharp increase to 77.7, up from 63.9 in November.
(Click on image to enlarge)
Source: Trading Economics, University of Michigan
Puplava noted that this 14-point jump marks one of the largest single-month increases in the index's history. While economists had anticipated a modest rise to 65.2, the actual figure far exceeded expectations, reflecting a significant boost in consumer confidence. This surge, likely influenced by the recent election, is a positive signal for consumer spending and economic momentum heading into 2025. However, Puplava emphasized the importance of monitoring whether this optimism sustains into the coming months.
Manufacturing Recovery: A Turning Point
Another focal point of the discussion was the improving outlook for the manufacturing sector. Puplava’s Financial Sense Wealth Management Stimulus Index, which tracks monetary policy and energy costs, projects a manufacturing rebound after more than two years of contraction.
(Click on image to enlarge)
Source: Bloomberg, Financial Sense Wealth Management. Note: The FSWM Stimulus Index is based on global central bank rates and their change over the previous 12 months.
Key metrics support this view:
- The S&P Global PMI for US Manufacturing rose to 49.7, just shy of the 50-point threshold that indicates expansion.
- The ISM Manufacturing PMI similarly improved to 48.4, exceeding consensus expectations.
- New Orders, a leading measure within the ISM Manufacturing Index, is now back into expansion territory.
These developments suggest that the manufacturing sector is in the process of stabilizing and likely nearing a transition to growth after nearly 2.5 years of contraction. Puplava explained that lower interest rates, declining energy costs, and central bank actions are setting the stage for recovery. He expects manufacturing to enter full growth mode by early 2025, with the recovery possibly continuing into the first half of 2026.
Auto Sales: A Leading Indicator for Growth
Puplava highlighted auto sales as a crucial indicator for both consumer demand and manufacturing activity. November’s annualized auto sales reached 16.5 million, up from 16.1 million in the previous month. This marks the highest level since mid-2021, signaling robust consumer demand and a potential boost to industrial production.
(Click on image to enlarge)
Source: Bloomberg, Financial Sense Wealth Management
For the manufacturing sector, increased auto sales mean reduced dealership inventories, which will likely lead to more production orders. Puplava believes this uptick in auto sales reflects broader economic traction and strengthens the case for a manufacturing rebound.
Competing Economic Scenarios: Roaring 2020s vs. Stagflationary 70s
Looking ahead, Puplava discussed two potential scenarios for the second half of the decade:
- The Roaring 2020s: A continuation of strong growth driven by technological innovation, productivity gains, and economic expansion.
- A Stagflationary 70s: A period characterized by higher-than-average inflation and compressed growth due to structural economic challenges.
While some experts are optimistic about a Roaring 20s productivity boom continuing through the back half of this decade, Puplava expresses a bit more caution about the longer-term outlook. He pointed to the U.S. debt-to-GDP ratio, which currently exceeds levels seen during both the 1920s and World War II. High debt levels could limit the economy’s ability to sustain strong growth, as rising interest rates and inflation place additional pressure on households and businesses.
Puplava warned that if long-term interest rates increase significantly, it could undermine key areas of recovery, such as housing and manufacturing. He noted that while growth is desirable, "too much of a good thing" could push rates and inflation to unsustainable levels, creating economic headwinds.
Investment Strategy: Volatility and Opportunity
Puplava advised investors to prepare for a decade of volatility, echoing predictions made by other market strategists, such as Felix Zulauf. He argued that the traditional buy-and-hold strategy may no longer be effective, given the cyclical nature of growth, inflation, and central bank intervention.
For now, Financial Sense Wealth Management has adopted a more aggressive stance, reflecting optimism about near-term economic improvements. However, Puplava cautioned that rising interest rates or inflation could prompt a shift back to defensive positioning in 2025. He stressed the need to remain adaptable and vigilant in navigating market fluctuations by closely monitoring global liquidity, credit markets, and other key indicators for assessing opportunities and risks as they arise over the year ahead.
Key Takeaways and Implications
Chris Puplava’s analysis underscores the dynamic and uncertain nature of the current economic environment. Key insights include:
- Consumer confidence is surging, which bodes well for spending and growth in the near term.
- Manufacturing is on the cusp of recovery, with improvements expected to continue into 2025 and beyond.
- Auto sales serve as a reliable leading indicator, pointing to increased industrial activity.
- High debt levels and rising interest rates pose risks to sustained economic growth, particularly in housing and manufacturing.
- Investors should embrace tactical strategies, as volatility is likely to define markets for the remainder of the decade.
Puplava’s outlook offers both caution and optimism, balancing the potential for recovery with the challenges posed by structural debt and inflation. As the economy navigates these competing forces, flexibility and foresight will be essential for investors to remain successful in building and preserving their wealth.
More By This Author:
How AI May Escalate Geopolitical ConflictsDoomberg On U.S. Energy Policy, Trump Vs. California, And Big Tech's Next Move
Why Dividends Make Sense In Today's Markets
Advisory services offered through Financial Sense® Advisors, Inc., a registered investment adviser. Securities offered through Financial Sense® Securities, Inc., Member FINRA/SIPC. DBA ...
more