An Uncommon Set-Up Signals Caution

shallow focus photograph of black and gray compass

February’s strong jobs gain was the latest in a slew of solid economic reports suggesting the US economy continues to recover from the 2020 recession, according to a note from Stifel on Monday.

"While no one data point can signal the US economy is out of the woods, coupled with recent gains in auto and retail spending and manufacturing as well as robust housing market activity, ongoing positive monthly job creation will work to boost confidence and drive higher expectations for more solid growth in the coming months and quarters," the report said.

Good point but remember that government bonds prefer misery because it keeps a cap on their mortal enemy, inflation. So the better the news for the economy, the worse for bonds and tech.

The bright side: Accelerating US economic growth has been the most significant driver of equity purchases by households during the past 30 years, according to Goldman Sachs. Net equity buying by households outpaced inflows from other sources when real yields and breakeven inflation were rising during that period, according to the brokerage.

Goldman lifted its household net equity demand outlook for 2021 to $350 billion from $100 billion and projects a doubling of corporate equity demand from the prior year to $300 billion.

Inflows into equity mutual funds and exchange-traded funds totaled $163 billion since the start of February, the largest five-week inflow on record in absolute dollar terms, according to Goldman analysts.

Now I’ve got some bad news — sorta, kinda, ish. Depends on how you feel about historical statistical analysis.

It’s not everyone’s cup of tea but I like it because I believe that investors tend to do the same things over and over again given similar emotional stimuli.

With that said, I have a friend who has been a pioneering, world-class statistical analyst for more than four decades – and is a top outside advisor to well known hedge fund managers. Can’t name either but trust me on this one.

He ran a study this afternoon — Tuesday, March 8 — to see what has ensued when the Nasdaq is down more than 2.2% on the same day the Dow is up more than 0.75%, as occurred today. The set-up has occurred 11 times since 1987, with most instances during the early stages of the 2000-2003 bear market.

The first and second following days were positive on average by 0.5% each, but it’s all downhill from there with an average loss of 1.9% on the fifth day, -3.6% the eighth day and -6.6% by the eleventh day, with 90% of instances negative.

The most recent instances were Jan 25, 2001, and March 8, 2001, and the average losses on the eleventh days were -10.2% and -11.1%.

In the March 8, 2001 case — exactly 20 years ago — the market fell 5.3% the first ensuing day and was down as much as -15.6% on the ninth ensuing day. Mind you in that case, the dot-com bear market was already a year old and still had another two years to go.

One of my mentors in the fund business used to say that market anomalies only persist until someone notices them. A wise observation to be sure, but I can see the foundational basis for this one to recur. Beware.

Big market timing decisions are not my thing, but if this history worries you, consider lightening up on exposure if we have a couple days of rebound in the Nasdaq.

Disclaimer: © 2021 MoneyShow.com, LLC. All Rights Reserved. 

How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience.

Comments

Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.