Taxing A Lovely Bunch Of Coconuts

I am often surprised by how many commenters say something to the effect, “I don’t get how taxing capital income is double taxing wage income.” Thus, here I’ll present a simple numerical example.

Imagine an island where residents produce 100 coconuts. They have the option of consuming the coconuts today, or planting them and having 200 coconuts in 10 years. In that case, the price of future consumption is 1/2 the price of current consumption.

Now assume this society introduces a 40% wage tax to fund public goods. You must pay a tax of 40%, or 40 coconuts, on your wage “income” of 100 coconuts. In that case you can consume 60 coconuts today, or plant the 60 and consume 120 coconuts in 10 years. The ratio is still 1 to 2, and the relative price of future coconuts is still 1/2 the price of current coconuts.

That sort of tax regime does not unfairly favor either current or future consumption.

Now someone suggests that in order to be “fair” we need to also have a 40% tax on capital gains, added on to the 40% wage tax. Now the person who choses to save the 60 coconuts (after paying the wage tax), faces another tax bill in 10 years. When the coconut trees mature, they pay a tax of 24 coconuts (40% on the capital gain of 60 coconuts.) They are left with 96 coconuts to consume (120 – 24).

In this case, the tax rate on current consumption is still 40%, but the tax rate of future consumption is 54% (200 – 96)/200. The choice is no longer between 100 coconuts today and 200 in ten years, or 60 today and 120 in 10 years. Now the choice is between 60 coconuts today and 96 in 10 years. People are being encouraged to eat their capital today, not save it and boost future consumption.

The best argument for a capital gains tax is that it prevents people from disguising wage income as capital gains. This is one reason that many countries set the capital gains tax rate at a level lower than the personal income tax rate. It is assumed that when someone sells their own business, some of the rise in the value of the business doesn’t just reflect saving, rather it derives from the owner’s labor in building up the business.

1 2
View single page >> |
How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience.


Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.