Inflation... Or Speculation?

In the great inflation debate (transitory or not), the rally in everything from copper to lumber has been a point in favor of the reflation hawks. But, as Bloombergs Tom Orlik notes, movements in commodity prices this year have been mainly driven by risk appetite, not fundamental demand or shortages of supply.

In other words, a majority of the realized 'inflation' in commodity prices is really driven by speculation on that inflation. As SocGen's Albert Edwards recently pointed out (echoing Bloomberg's John Authers' recent note), there is a "reflexivity" to investors' belief in rising inflation.

"For when they pile into commodities as an investment vehicle to benefit from rising inflation, they create substantial upstream cost  pressures – as has been highlighted by PMI corporate surveys. Beyond the cascading effect of upstream commodity price pressures, headline CPIs are also quickly impacted as  food and energy prices rip higher.

"In addition to this, the observation by investors that industrial commodity prices are rising only serves to reaffirm their belief about cyclical strength and rising inflation - most especially 'Dr Copper,' which many investors see as extremely sensitive to economic conditions.

"The circular, or as George Soros terms it, ‘reflexive’ nature of financial markets makes them extremely vulnerable to being whipsawed.  Yet because of the current extreme momentum it would take a very heavy weight of evidence to convince this market to reverse direction."

However, as the recent rapid decline of numerous industrial metals (and lumber) from their peak suggests, a rise in commodity prices driven primarily by speculation is also prone to a sudden reversal. So the inflationists' argument may not be as strong as it first appears, and the debate is far from over.

By way of contrast, Goldman Sachs disagrees, noting there is a long history of attributing paradigm shifts in prices to speculation.

1 2
View single page >> |

Disclosure: Copyright ©2009-2021 Media, LTD; All Rights Reserved. Zero Hedge is intended for Mature Audiences. Familiarize yourself with our legal and use policies ...

How did you like this article? Let us know so we can better customize your reading experience.


Leave a comment to automatically be entered into our contest to win a free Echo Show.